SUPREME COURT-First Dept.-Cont'd. | SUPREME COURT—Second Dept.-O't'd.
Justices of the First District-Cont'd. Justices of the Second District-Cont'd.
WILLIAM P. BURR.

LEANDER B. FABER,
F. J. GLENNON.

AANON L. SQUIRES.
GEORGE V. MULLAN.

WALTER H. JAYCOX.
RICHARD H. MITCHELL,
JOHN V. MCAVOY.

Justices of the Ninth District,
ROBERT F. WAGNER.

MARTIN J. KEOGH.
RICHARD P. LYDON.
PHILIP J. McCOOK.

JOSEPH MORSCHAUSER.
ARTHUR S. TOMPKINS.
J. ADDISON YOUNG.

WILLIAM P. PLATT.
Second Department.

ALBERT H. F. SEEGER.
Justices of the Appellate Division.

Third Department.
ALMET F. JENKS, PRESIDING JUSTICE.
ASSOCIATE JUSTICES.

Justices of the Appellato Division.
ISAAC N. MILLS.

JOHN M. KELLOGG, PRESIDING JUSTICE.
ADELBERT P. RICH.
HARRINGTON PUTNAM.

ASSOCIATE JUSTICES.
ABEL E. BLACKMAR.

JOHN WOODWARD.
WILLIAM J. KELLY.

AARON V. S. COCHRANE.
WALTER H. JAYCOX.

HENRY T. KELLOGG.

MICHAEL H. KILEY.
Justices of the Appellate Term, 1920.

Justices of the Third District,
March.

WESLEY 0. HOWARD.
LESTER W. CLARK.

WILLIAM P. RUDD.
CHARLES H. KELBY.

GILBERT D. B. HASBROUCK,
DAVID F. MANNING.

CHARLES E. NICHOLS.
May.

HAROLD J. HINMAN.
LESTER W. CLARK.

Justices of the Fourth District.
CHARLES H. KELBY.
DAVID F. MANNING.

CHARLES C. VAN KIRK.

EDWARD C. WHITMYER.
September.

HENRY V. BORST.
LESTER W. CLARK.

GEORGE R. SALISBURY.
CHARLES H. KELBY,
DAVID F. MANNING,

Justices of the Sixth District,
December.

GEORGE MCCANN.
LESTER W. CLARK.

ROWLAND L, DAVIS.
CHARLES H. KELBY.

ABRAHAM L. KELLOGG.
DAVID F, MANNING,

THEODORE R. TUTHILL.

Justices of the Second District.

WILLIAM J. KELLY.
JOSEPH ASPINALL,
LESTER W. CLARK.
TOWNSEND SCUDDER.
ABEL E. BLACKMAR.
ISAAC M. KAPPER.
HARRINGTON PUTNAM.
CHARLES H. KELBY.
RUSSELL BENEDICT.
JAMES C. VAN SICLEN.
ALMET F. JENKS.
DAVID F. MANNING.
STEPHEN CALLAGHAN.
JAMES C. CROPSEY.
EDIVARD LAZANSKY.
LEWIS L. FAWCETT,

Fourth Department.
Justices of the Appellate Division,
FREDERICK W. KRUSE, PRESIDING JUSTICE.

ASSOCIATE JUSTICES.
JOHN S. LAMBERT.
PASCAL C. J. DE ANGELIS.
IRVING G. HUBBS.
WILLIAM W. CLARK.

Justices of the Fifth District.

IRVING R. DEVENDORF.
EDGAR C. EMERSON.
LEONARD C. CROUCH,
WILLIAM M, ROSS.

(182 N.Y.S.) SUPREME COURT-Fourth Dept.-O’t’d. CITY COURT OF NEW YORK. Justices of the Seventh District.

EDWARD F. O'DWYER, CHIEF JUSTICE.
SAMUEL N. SAWYER.

ASSOCIATE JUSTICES.
ADOLPH J. RODENBECK.

ALEXANDER FINELITE.
ROBERT F. THOMPSON.

PETER SCHMUCK.
BENJAMIN B. CUNNINGHAM,

EDWARD B. LA FETRA.
JOHN B. M. STEPHENS.

JOHN L. WALSH,
ABRAHAM G. MEYER.

LOUIS A, VALENTE,
Justices of the Eighth District.

THOMAS T, REILLY,

LOUIS WENDEL, JR.
LOUIS W. MARCUS.

JOSEPH M. CALLAHAN.
CHARLES B. WHEELER.
CHARLES H. BROWN.

COURT OF CLAIMS.
CHARLES A. POOLEY.
HARRY L. TAYLOR.

FRED M. ACKERSON, PRESIDING JUDGE.
WESLEY G. DUDLEY.

JUDGES,
GEORGE W. COLE.

WILLIAM W. WEBB.
CHARLES B. SEARS.

SANFORD W. SMITH.
PHILIP, A. LAING.

WILLIAM D. CUNNINGHAM,
ALONZO G. HINCKLEY.

CHARLES MORSCHAUSER.

CASES REPORTED

Page

Page
Aaron Littman & Co., H. F. Bindseil & Son Amos Coal Co., Alden Coal Mining Co. v.
v. (Sup.)

176
(Sup.)

819 Abbaticchio v. Abbatacchio (Sup.)

913 | Amsden, Traders' Nat. Bank v. (Sup.). 954 Abeles, Motor Car Equipment Co. v. (Sup.) 938 Amsterdam Bldg. Co., Burton v. (Sup.).... 917 Acheson Graphite Co., Minardi v. (Sup.).. 937 Amsterdam & Batavia Handelsvereeniging Acker, Merrall & Condit Co., McDonald v. v. Marquette (Sup.)...

913 (Sup.) 607 Anderson, Cochran v. (Sup.).

265 Acme finishing Co., James Talcott, Inc. v., Andrew Gulick & Co. v. Cyclemotor Cortwo cases (Sup.) 930 poration (Sup.)

316 Adams, Groat 1. (Sup.). 927 Andrews, Fitts v. (Sup.).

464 Addison Electric Light & Power Co., Hubbs Appell's Estate, In re (Sup.).

913 v. (Sup.)

152 | Appointment of Two Trustees of City and Adler v. Í. D. Wolfson, Inc. (Sup.) 288 County Hall, In re (Sup.).

918 Adler, Kannengiesser v. (Sup.). 931 Arabol Mfg. Co. v. Blum (Sup.)

913 A. D. Smith Sons Co., Miller Bros. Hat Archer, Sanders v. (Sup.)...

949 Co. v. (Sup.)

937 Argos Mercantile Corporation, Richardson Agency of Canadian Car & Foundry Co., v. (Sup.)

891 Nitro Powder Co. v. (Sup.).

940 Armbrow Operating Corporation, Bronson Aikens v. Coney Island & B. R. Co. (Sup.) 913 v. (Sup.)

916 Akron Bldg. Co., Munds v. (Sup.). 938 Arnett, Shane v. (Sup.).

950 Alberti v. Ferrado (Mun. Ct. Ñ. Y.)... 500 | Aronson, Blumenfeld v. (Sup.).

915 Albert Schwill & Co., Lekas & Dr as v. Aronstein v. Taylor (Sup.)..

913 (Sup.)

933 Asch v. Hoyt-Messinger Corporation (Sup.) 914 Albert T, Otto & Sons, Maag v. (Sup.).. 935 Assets & Liabilities Ass'n v. New York Albrecht v. Chelsea 'Fireproof Storage Lodge, No. 1, B. P. O. E. (Sup.).. 914 Warehouse Co. (Sup.). 913 Atkinson's Adm'r, In re (Sup.).

780
Alden Coal Mining Co. v. C. L. Amos Coal Atlantic Coast Shipping Co., Simpson v.
Co. (Sup.).

819
(Sup.)

331 Aldrich, Babcock v. (Sup.).

914 Atlantic Nat. Bank, Portugese American Alexander v. Lounsbury (Sup.) 913 Bank v. (Sup.)

945 Alcxander v. Scottsville Sand & Gravel Co. Atwater, People v. (Sup.)

941 (Sup.) 913 Aubin v. Wadsworth (Sup.).

914 A. L. Gosselin Corporation v. Mario Tap- Austin Nichols Co., Dechterow v., three casparelli fu Pietro of America (Sup.)..... 913 es (Sup.)

921 A. L. Guidone & Sons, Coleman V., two Austin, Nichols & Co. v. Jobes (Sup.).

777 cases (Sup.)

625 | Automobile Ins. Co. of Hartford, Conn., Allen v. Haynes (Sup.) 913 Ross v. (Sup.)

947 Allen v. Oscar G. Murray Railroad Em- Avedon v. Gem Dress House (Sup.) 914 ployés' Ben. Fund (Sup.) 369 | Averett v. Averett (Sup.).

914 Allers v. Allers (Sup.)

913 | A. & B. Export & Import Corporation v. Alt, Charlop v. (Sup.)..

630 Franco-American Chemical

Co.,

two Altieri, Dauere v. (Sup.).. 921 cases (Sup.)....

914 Amel, Madison Costume Co. v. (Sup.). 774 American Cent. Ins. Co. of St. Louis, Mo., Babbino v. Babbino (Sup.).

914 Young v. (Sup.). 959 Babcock v. Aldrich (Sup.)

914 American Cinema Corporation, Michel v. Bachnor Bros. Co., Fox v. (Sup.)

416 (Sup.) 588 Ball v. Cross (Sup.).

914 American Cities Co., Travis v. (Sup.). 394 Ball v. New York (Sup.)

914 American Ry. Exp. Co., Esposito v. (Sup.) 97 Ball, Rourke v. (Sup.)

948 American Ry. Exp. Co., Esposito v. (Sup.) 923 Balmat, McLear v. (Sup.).

936 American Ry. Exp. Co., Roe v. (Sup.).... 8:15 Banca Bergamasca di Depositi e Conti CorAmerican Ry. Exp. Co., Schiff v. (Sup.)... 679 renti, Patent Vulcanite Roofing Co. v. American Woolen Co. of New York, Cohen (Sup.)

941 v. (Sup.) 919 Banker. Burchetta v. (Sup.).

917 Amerigus Realty Corporation, Bullowa v. Barberio v. Brandeles (Sup.).

914 (Sup.) 917 | Barker, In re (Sup.)..

914 Barnett, Inc., Bulova v. (Sup.).

808 182 N.Y.S.

(viii)

(182 N.Y.S.) Page

Page Barney B. Jacobs Co., In re (Sup.). ... 914 Board of Sup'rs of Orange County, People Barrett, Cohen v. (Sup.).... 919 ex rel. Hirshberg v. (Sup.).

944 Barrios, Fairfax Hotel Co. v. (Sup.). 923 Board of Sup'rs of Orange County, People Barter v. Hines (Sup.).. 914 ex rel. McCord v. (Sup.)...

944 Barthel, In re (Sup.).

914 Board of Sup'rs of Rockland County, In re Barton Lighterage Co. v. La Brecque Co.

(Sup.)

915 (Sup.) 170 Bob v. Goldstein (Sup.)

915 Barud v. Secular (Sup.). 693 Boehm v. Holzkamp (Sup.).

915 Basso v. John T. Clark & Son (Sup.) 914 Boiardi v. Marden, Orth & Hastongs CorBaum v. Breslauer (Sup.).. 906 poration (Sup.).

916 Bay v. Bay (Sup.). 914 | Bongartz, Berry v. (Sup.)

915 Beam, Nelson v. (Sup.).. 939 Born, Inc., Spitzer v. (Sup.)..

327 Beard, McMahon v. (Sup.). 475 Bors' Estate, In re (Sup.).

916 Becher, Curfein v. (Sup.)...

920 Bossert & Sons v. Piel Bros. (Sup.). 620 Becker's Aniline & Chemical Works, Sofield Boston & M. R. R. v. Standard Wall Pav. (Sup.) 691 per Co. (Sup.)..

916 Becker's Aniline & Chemical Works, Wo- Boughton, In re (Sup.)

440 field v. (Sup.) 958 Bouton, Hobby v. (Sup.).

929 Beckett's Ex'rs, In re (Sur.). 571 Bowen v. Collins (Sup.).

916 B. Edmund David, Inc., Elm Costume Co. Bowlby, Peck v. (Sup.)...

941 v. (Sup.).... 312 Boyd, Sullivan v. (Sup.).

953 Beekman v. Stern (Sup.) 915 Brach & Sons, Hoffenberg v. (Sup.).

929 Beir, McGuiness v. (Sup.). 936 Bramer, Von Kamp v. (Sup.)..

956 Beling v. Deutscher (Sup.) 915 Brandeles, Barberio v. (Sup.)...

914 Belmont v. New York (Sup.)

173 Brandenburg v. Eclipse Mach. Co., two Belmont v. New York (Sup.) 175 cases (Sup.).

916 Bender's Estate, In re (Sur.) 217 | Brandt Co. v. Engelhardt (Sup.).

618 Benesch, Woodruff v. (Sup.). 880 Brazill v. Weed (Sup.)..

350 Berardini, Garbarino v. (Sup.). 925 Brazill, Weed v. (Sup.)...

353 Berel's Estate, In re (Sur.). 91 Brazill, Wecd v. (Sup.)...

354 Berg, In re (Sup.).. 915 Brazill, Weed v. (Sup.)...

353 Bergen v. Suydam (Sup.) 915 Bregstone v. Greenberg (Sup.).

340 Berger v. Wexler (Sup.)..

915 Bregstone v. Greenberg, two cases (Sup.) 916 Berlin v. E. S. Kuh & Valk Co. (Sup.) 915 Breidbart, Henderson Importing Co. v. Bernheim, Stevold v. (Sup.). 952 (Sup.)

169 Berry v. Bongartz (Sup.). 915 Breitung v. Stieglitz (Sup.).

916 Berton v. Snyder (Sup.). 915 Brennan v. Hampton (Sup.).

916 Bevins, Gordon v. (Sup.). 926 Breslauer, Baum v. (Sup.)

906 Biggs v. Steinway & Sons (Sup.). 101 Brett v. Brett (Sup.).

916 Bijur v. Serlis (Sup.). 915 Brigham v. New York (Sup.)

145 Bijur, Young v. (Sup.).. 803 Brigham v. New York (Sup.).

916 Bindseil & Son v. Aaron Littman & Co. British & Colonial Kinematograph Co., (Sup.). 176 Carroll v. (Sup.)

918 Bishop, Dunn v. (Sup.). 922 Brobst's Estate, In re (Sur.).

532 Bishop, Exchange Bank of Oakfield v. Brock v. Poor (Sup.)..

916 (Sup.)

923 Bronson v. Armbrow Operating CorporaBishop, Standard Code Co. v. (Sup.). 951 tion (Sup.).

916 Blake-Daniels Co., New York Income Cor- Bronx Parkway Commission, Appeal of poration v. (Sup.)... 939 (Sup.)

760 Blanchard, Gohlke v. (Sup.).

926 Bronx Parkway Commission, In re (Sup.) 916 Blasco, Bufano v. (Sup.).

917 Brooklyn City R. Co. v. Whalen (Sup.) 283 Blath, Inc., v. Young (Sup.).

958 Brooklyn Majestic Theater Co. v. VitaB. L. B. Motor Repair Co., Greif v. (Sup.) 765 graph Co. of America (Sup.).

916 Bleistift, In re (Sup.). 915 Brown, In re (Sup.).....

917 Blitzer v. Gellering (Sup.) 915 Brown, Chase v. (Sup.)

918 Block v. Robitscher (Sup.). 773 Brown, People v. (Sup.). .

115 Blum, Arabol Mfg. Co. v. (Sup.) 913 Brown's Estate, In re (Sur.)

728 Blum v. Gerardi (Sup.) 297 Brownell, G. Elias & Bro. v. (Sup.).

925 Blumenfeld v. Aronson (Sup.). 915 Brownstone, Vells v. (Sup.)..

957 Blumstein, Randall v. (Sup.). 946 Bruggemann v. Bruggemann (Sup.).

87 Board of Education of City of New York, Bruggemann v. Bruggemann (Sup.)

917 Egan v. (Sup.).... 922 Buchler, Rossi v. (Sup.)..

948 Board of Education of City of New York, Buck, Emerson v. (Sup.).

385 Kelly v. (Sup.). 931 Budde, People v. (Sup.)..

941 Board of Education of City of New York, Budracco v. National Surety Co. (Sup.).. 590 People ex rel. Ajas v. (Sup.). 943 Bufano v. Blasco (Sup.)..

917 Board of Education of Union Free School Buff-Merz v. Ratkowsky (Sup.)

162 Dist. No. 9 of the Town of Cheektowaga, Buff-Merz v. Ratkowsky (Sup.).

917 Crego v. (Sup.)

920 Bullard, Municipal Investing Co. v., two Board of Sup’rs of Orange County, People cases (Sup.)

938 ex rel. Gregg v. (Sup.)

943

V.

Page

Page Bullowa 7. Amerigus Realty Corporation Church v. Church (Sup.).

918 (Sup.) 917 Chysky v. Drake Bros. Co. (Sup.)

459 Bull's Will, In re (Sur.). 725 Cioffi v. Pisani (Sup.)

918 Bulova v. E. L. Barnett, Inc. (Sup.). 808 City of Albany, Laut v. (Sup.).

183 Bunt, In re (Sup.)....

434 City of Buffalo, Haecker Sterling Co. v. Burchetta v. Banker (Sup.). 917 (Sup.)

927 Burkwitt v. New Jersey Fidelity & Plate City of Buffalo v. Till (Sup.)

418 Glass Ins. Co. (Sup.)...

689 City of Jamestown, Postal Telegraph Cable Burr v. Carlton (Sup.). 917 Co. v. (Sup.).

945 Burr v. Voorhis (Sup.)

917 City of Mt. Vernon, New York Interurban Burton v. Amsterdam Bldg. Co. (Sup.).. 917 Water Co. v. (Sup.)..

940 Buscaglia v. Chadeayne (Sup.).. 917 | City of New York, Ball v. (Sup.)..

914 Bustanoby, Inc., Stoll v. (Sup.).

952 City of New York, Belmont v. (Sup.)..... 173 Butler, Finnegan v. (Sup.)...

671 City of New York, Belmont v. (Sup.). .... 175

City of New York, Brigham v. (Sup.).... 145 Cabana Holstein-Friesian Ass'n of City of New York, Brigham v. (Sup.)..... 916 America (Sup.)...