Page images

orators; but it certainly does come to pass that prac- dling together of undergraduates by the thousands. It tically all of them acquire the ability to stand upon grows out of a confusion of ideas, and out of that their feet in a public place and say anything that transitional and bewildered condition in which half they may have occasion to say with directness and a dozen important Eastern institutions have found without undue einbarrassment or confusion of man- themselves by reason of their attempts to be univerner. If one should compare a hundred Eastern sities and colleges at the same time, without recoggraduates of the present month of June with a hun- nizing any distinction between a “ college boy" and dred Western graduates, it would probably appear a “university man.” Perhaps it is time that the that the former would somewhat excel in a certain tables were turned, and that the task of criticism air of ease, polish and maturity in private conversa- were directed to the anomalous group of great education,-while the young Westerners would unques- tional caravansaries. The local or small endowed tionably prove themselves immensely superior on the college, which occupies so characteristic a place in the average, if a sudden emergency required some public American educational system, is precisely the type of expression of views. Of course the differences either institution of which we have best reason to be proud. way would not be nearly so marked at the end of This is a digression, but it has pertinence. It is ten years after leaving college. In the long run the because Ohio, Indiana, Illinois, Iowa, Michigan, Wischief factor of successful public speech consists in consin, Minnesota and the other Western states have having something to say. It is not often that a man each its group of small colleges that the Western who possesses—in his knowledge of a theme or in his system of inter-collegiate oratorical contests has zealous convictions—the subject-matter of a speech, grown up. Each college has its local oratorical assois unable after a little practice to speak with a ciation ; and the so-called “home contest" is one of the reasonable degree of success. Nevertheless, some or- great occasions of the year. It stands at the apex of atorical training at the very period when the mind all the efforts of the literary societies to train their of a man is forming, and his stock of facts and ideas members in the kindred arts of writing and speakis growing most rapidly, must have its great ad- ing. After each college has held its home contest vantages.

and selected its champion for the year, the “state The natural and wholesome rivalry among the contest” occurs under the auspices of the intercolliterary societies of any given college might easily legiate oratorical association of the state. Some cenhave been expected to point the way to periodical tral town like the state capital is chosen as the scene contests in which the different societies would be of the competition, or else the different college towns represented by their champion orators and debaters. are selected in rotation year after year. Following And from competitive oratory within the college the several state contests comes the grand final comwalls, in this era of inter-collegiate relationships petition between the representatives of the different which so curiously combine the spirit of competition states which are included in the association, with the spirit of co-operation, it is not a long step to In the contest which was held this year at Galesthe inter-collegiate oratorical contest.

burg, Illinois, the competing states were Ohio, InThe numerous colleges which have been planted in diana, Illinois, Wisconsin, Minnesota, Iowa, Nethe Mississippi valley states have constituted a theme braska, Colorado, Kansas and Missouri. The numfor much disparagement from sources none too well ber of colleges banded together to form this interstate informed. If one will but keep in mind a reasonable association may be estimated at nearly one hundred, distinction between the proper work of the American -an average of about ten to each of the ten states, college on the one hand, and the post-graduate and although it happens that some state groups are much professional work of a great university on the more numerous than ten and others much less. If a other, he may easily find much ground for defend- hundred colleges are thus concerned, it may be estiing and for praising the college system of the mated that in each college an average of ten students states west of the Alleghany Mountains. A cen- will make more or less serious effort to enter the pretral state university with its series of special liminary or home contests. Thus the final victory schools for advanced study and research, and with may be considered as one gained over a thousand its group of professional and technical colleges, is competitors who have entered the lists at the outset. worthy of all commendation. But for the best re- And when one further considers the indirect influence sults in strictly collegiate, that is to say, undergrad- of the contests upon the work of the debating socieuate work, it may well be claimed that ten well ties, and upon various other oratorical and literary organized colleges with five hundred students apiece, efforts in the student communities of the West, the properly distributed through a state, will be product magnitude of this oratorical impulse becomes apparive of better results than would one great central ent. college, in which several thousand undergraduates So generally indeed has it affected young America would find themselves massed, subject to the instruc- in the Mississippi valley that the students from these tion of transient tutors and perfunctory assistant states who go to the eastern colleges and universities professors. It is a curious new heresy in educa- almost invariably take the contagion with them. tional methods,—this American opinion which holds Thus in the recent inter-collegiate debates, in which that there can be no sort of disadvantage in the hud- the students of several of the largest Eastern colleges have participated, nearly all the successful speakers Minnesota ; Professor John R. Commons, of the Inhave been young men who live, and who have pre- diana State University, and the Rev. Dr. Willard pared for college, in the Mississippi valley states. Scott, of Chicago. The judges who were present in

This Western passion for oratory, although it has order to decide upon the delivery of the speakers been stimulated and sustained by the inter collegiate were themselves accomplished in the practice of pubcontests, was widespread and fervent before the in- lic speaking, two of them having national fame as terstate organization had its beginning. The credit orators. They were Ex-Senator Ingalls, of Kansas ; of proposing the existing organization is due to stu- the Hon. W. J. Bryan, of Nebraska, and Governor dents of Knox College at Galesburg, Ni. The first in- Jackson, of Iowa. terstate contest was actually held on February 27, Western college oratory has fashions of its own. 1874, the competing speakers representing only the Generally speaking it is somewhat high-keyed and states of Iowa, Illinois and Wisconsin. The move- artificial. It strives after epigram, revels in antiment rapidly grew until ten states were admitted thesis, and after twenty years of the two-thousandinto the association. The constitution requires that word limit, it has tended to become terse and intense. the orations shall not be over two thousand words in Its principal fault, perhaps, is its undue devotion to length, and the instructions to the judges are exceed- phrase-making. Mr. Hauerbach's speech in defense ingly minute. Nobody has ever yet invented a satis- of compromise, which has carried off this year's in. factory systein of marking, and much criticism some- terstate honors, does not show the characteristics of times results from the decisions arrived at, par- the typical college speech in their extremest forms. ticularly in the “home” and state contests. For the Nevertheless, it is representative of the method. The interstate occasion six judges are chosen, none of following paragraphs constitute the last half of Mr. whom can have any relation whatever with the col- Hauerbach's oration : leges represented in the contest, and no two of whom

We say that the blood of the Civil War redeemed the can come from the same state. Three of the judges

nation. But was the Union saved when the war ceased ? are selected for a previous marking of the written

Did the contest for civil rights end there? Secession was orations upon their merits as pieces of literary com- dead. But that malign spirit which had hovered in the position and for the intellectual ability they reveal. rear of the battle was not dead. Exultingly it came to The other three judges pass upon the oratorical manner the front. “The right of conquest and spoliation !” was and delivery of the speakers as evinced in the actual its only message to the prostrate South. Those dark days contest. Each judge makes his marks without con:

of reconstruction followed. Envy, hate and passion sultation with the others, and by a somewhat com

threatened to plunge the wounded nation into deeper

gloom. Now, alas, was the Union rent in twain ! After plex system of averages the final result is attained.

all, had not Lincoln lived and died in vain ? No! Men, In the recent contest two states were represented by

for a time, might forget his voice, but the spirit of toleryoung ladies. These were Miss Ethel M. Brown, of

ance and liberality by which he was inspired can never Oskaloosa College, who appeared as Iowa's champion, die. Counseling forgiveness, amnesty, and peace, it rose and Miss Nellie E. Wood, of Earlham College, who at last above the wrangling of the petty spoilsman of the represented Indiana. The full list of topics and North and the vindictive mutterings of the proud Southspeakers was as follows:

erner, conquered but unsubdued, to verify in the most

glorious reconciliation of all time that prophecy of old, “American Literary Genius,” E. B. Sherman, Univer- “Good tidings shall bind up the broken-hearted, and to sity of Nebraska.

them that mourn give beauty for ashes, the oil of joy for “The Better Personality,” C. W. Wood, Beloit College, mourning, and the garment of praise for the spirit of Wisconsin.

heaviness." “The Statecraft of Napoleon,” T. L. Anderson, Central Lincoln the compromiser ! It is in this rôle that his true College, Mo.

grandeur and beauty of character shine forth. In the “The Province of Law," Forrest Woodside, Kansas North, impatient friends urged him to issue at once the State Normal.

emancipation proclamation. Wendell Phillips denounced · The Hero of Compromise," 0. A. Hauerbach, Knox him as a "slave hound.” From the South all manner of College, Ill.

obloquy was hurled against him. In the midst of the “Our Nation's Perpetuity,” Miss Nellie Wood, Earlham storm stood Lincoln : “With malice toward none, with College, Ind.

charity for all," he calmly waited the decree from a higher “Reserve Power,” A. C Baldwin, Dennison University, source than human lips. He must needs use a hand of Ohio.

iron, but it was gloved in the velvet of pity. In the death “Fidelity to Its Ideal–Our Nation's Safeguard,” E. M. of Abraham Lincoln the South lost her truest friend, Phillips, Hamlin University, Minn.

the North and the Union its most noble defender. “A Plea for Shylock," Miss Ethel Brown, Oskaloosa A nation is prone to glorify its successful general above College, Iowa.

him who in legislative halls quietly guards his country's “Social Progress,” W. N. Schafer, University of Colo- liberties. Is it true that all the elements of courage and rado.

virtue belong to martial success ? It is indeed a thrilling Mr. Hauerbach, of Knox College, Illinois, carried

scene-the conqueror resplendent in crimson robe and off the first honors, and the second place was awarded

victor's crown, cheered by shouts of victory and songs of

triumph. But in the light of a Christian age that picture to Mr. C. W. Wood, of Beloit College, Wisconsin.

changes. The notes of triumph cannot drown the deThe judges who had passed upon the manuscripts in spairing wail of defeat ; the joyful song of the conqueror advance were United States Senator C. K. Davis, of is turned to harsh and hideous discord by the dying groans of the conquered. That robe is crimson-aye, taire with that of a personality such as Victor Hugo with the blood of fathers ! The gems that sparkle in that creates in Bienvenu, the bishop. If Mr. Hauerbach's crown, are they aught but the frozen tears of widowed oration reflects the practical political philosophy of motherhood ? The enemy of war, the champion of peace,

the day, Mr. Wood's seems even more distinctly to will yet be crowned the hero of modern civilization !

reflect the spirit of the new Christian sociology, of There is no more auspicious sign of the world's progress to-day than the increasing tendency toward universal

which one now reads and hears so much. The conarbitration The world is coming to recognize that the cluding half of Mr. Wood's oration was as follows: Pan-American Congress was based upon a principle of Here is a battlefield for your historians to make note of. greater importance and wider significance than a mere Turn the pages of history and read where great statesselfish compact for national aggrandizement. The ruddy men have met and solved the vital problems of nations, glow of Mars begins to pale before the silvery light of where mighty warriors have faced each other and worked Bethlehem's star, fixed in the heavens amidst the chant out the great possibilities of their peoples, and yet I would ing of angel choirs—“Peace on earth, good will toward put up against them all this simple meeting of Jean Valmen." The groans of a peasantry ground down by tax- jean and Bienvenu. For upon such meetings depends the ation for standing armies shall yet be answered. The na- destiny of man. tions of the earth will yet learn that bonds of love bind W eary, sore and bleeding at heart, Jean Valjean stands more securely than bands of iron.

helpless in the presence of the bishop, asking himself Shall it be the American people who will teach the these questions : “Why has this man taken me in? Why world this blessed lesson? Ample is their opportunity. does he trust me beneath his roof? He does not shrink War struck from the slave his shackles of iron, but it did from me, but even touches me. Can it be possible that not free his mind from the darkness of ignorance and he has any love for such a one as I am ? Ah ! I can superstition. No sabre stroke or cannon shot can cut answer that,” says Jean. “It is part of his business to down the gloomy wall of race prejudice in the South. do this. He is paid for it. Show me the man who does Only concessions and forbearance can avert the impend- good because it is right, and that is the man I will foling horrors of a race war. Riots and strikes almost daily low." Jean had no faith in men, for the simple reason proclaim social disorders. The gulf between wealth and that men had no faith in him. He needed a soul friend, poverty widens. In the very centres of our civilization who could love him not for what he was but for what he are want and suffering enough to sicken him who does might become. not blind his eyes or steel his heart. Among working Watch the scene the next morning in the house of the classes there is a general feeling of dissatisfaction and bit- bishop, and you will say that Jean has found this friend. terness. The spirit of the age is one of unrest, of break- In this scene you will see the culmination of all influences ing away from the old lines of thought and action.

arid the starting point of the evolution of a life which has A sign of progress this may be, but it is il such times simply existed into one which truly lives. as these that false ideas of heroism mislead the masses. Bid your political economists look for a moment at the Strong, unscrupulous men, exponents of blind popular sympathy of Bienvenu for this poor, half-starved, dedesires or fierce partisan passion, may precipitate a nation spised outcast, and they will write a new book upon the into all the horrors of a revolution. The lurid flame of science, convinced that they must use more heart in order anarchy, the smoke of the soldier's rifle, which have so to make their political economy practical. recently disgraced and startled more than one American Call your lovers of law and let them look in upon city, teach a twofold lesson. They who defy Justice Bienvenu as he administers “a cup of cold water” to this must bear her frown ; they who would seek her altars man while civil law demonstrates that man should "renmust respect the sovereignty of her law! The time has der under Cæsar the things that are Cæsar's," and they come when our nation's safety lies not in the skillful use will learn that when civil law casts loose from divine law of the sword, but in the right use of mind and heart. it ceases to restrain crime and enforce order. Divine law May society be deaf to the appeals of the rash agitator goes hand in hand with civil law in ruling the universe. and ignorant dem'gogue ! May men learn to heed the The personality of one is stamped upon the personality of voice of him whose soul is large enough to feel that all the other. We need a Parkhurst to join hands with have rights ; a man with mind and judgment keen enough municipal law and thus fathom out the great and grand to discover the source of a grievance, with strength and possibilities of all true government. Build your prison courage to relieve it by just and fair compromise!

houses, but forget not to build your temples. The evolution of the world's hero has been the index of The law and duty of the detective in this scene were not man's moral progress. The despised of yesterday becomes powerful enough to put Jean in his right place in life, for the honored of to-day. Humility to the Roman soldier they lacked heart and soul. But when Bienvenu steps in meant disgrace ; to-day it is “the meek who shall inherit and exhibits the principle of sympathy and love, comthe earth." Brute force must yield before the higher bined with that of law and duty, Jean Valjean swings power of moral courage. The compromiser, willing to around into the orbit of the Divine Universe. What was renounce the glory of partisan popularity, daring, in his it in the personality of Bienvenu that brought about this love for all, to meet the enmity of all, may hear himself wonderful change in the life and character of Jean? denounced by party hate as “weakling," "coward,” What was it ? Listen, and you will hear it speaking to “traitor ;” but when the clouds of human pride and you as it has spoken to struggling humanity for over prejudice shall roll away, men will unite with Heaven in eighteen centuries. The very air we breathe is ladened proclaiming him a hero, a hero in the largest and truest with it, the sunshine that we see and feel has this sense, inspired by unselfish devotion to a high and worthy message wrapped up in every molecule and atom. purpose, a purpose to serve not self, not party, not men, Come with me to far off Judea, to the manger, on the Debut Man

cember morning, and you will see it wrapped in swaddling Mr. Wood's oration, which won the second place, is

clothes. Behold with your tear-filled eyes that bleeding

cross on Calvary's mount, and you will see that it is slain a comparison of the character and influence of a Vol

by the raging hands of a mob; bend over the tomb which

was rent on Resurrection morning, and you will see that 1874–First, T. Edward Egbert, Chicago University ; it is filled with this glorious message,

“ Thou art thy second, George T. Foster, Beloit College. brother's keeper.”

1875—First, Thomas I. Coultas, Ilinois Wesleyan UniverThis is the message that binds nation to nation, and in sity; second, Thomas W. Graydon, Iowa State University. the circle of human events it substitutes personality for

1876—First, Charles T. Noland, Central College ; second, individuality, and all nations of men are known under the

Miss Laura A. Kent, Antioch College. one title, the human race. You take this message into

1877—First, Olin A. Curtis, Lawrence University ; secyour life and your personality becomes one that will pierce the walls of China, it will build up Christianity in

ond, S. Frank Pronty, Central College. the heart of pagan India, or lay down its life not in vain

1878–First, E. A. Bancroft, Knox College ; second, J. on the arid soil of darkest Africa. In fact, you will pre

Gerry Eberhart, Cornell College. vail to level all races and nations up to the high plane 1879—First, R. M. La Follette, Wisconsin University ; where you yourself stand. Would you keep the Ten second, J. A. Barber, Oberlin College. Commandments? Then by all means grasp hold of this 1880—First, L. C. Harris, Iowa College ; second, Richmessage. Would you reform society? Then make this

ard Yates, Illinois College. your motto. Would you build up a great and national

1881–First, Charles F. Coffin, De Pauw University ; life? Then make this the pivot around which circles

second, Owen Morris, Carleton College. your code of laws. This message becomes the greatest element in molding

1882—First, Frank G. Hanchett, Chicago University'; the personality of man so that his influence results in

second, Arthur J. Craven, Iowa State University. good. Long before the cannon of the French Revolution

1883–First, John M. Ross, Monmouth College ; second, had thundered out its first charge Voltaire heard this

Daniel M. Kellogg, Beloit College. same message and might have regenerated France. But 1884—First, Charles T. Wyckoff, Knox College ; seche did not believe in the Christ. When Bienvenu heard ond, George L. Mackintosh, Wabash College. it, he had his eyes fixed upon that bleeding cross and his 1885–First, Albert J. Beveridge, De Pauw University ; feet firm upon the Rock of Faith. Out of the principles

second, Victor E. Bender, Knox College. of Voltaire grew the criminal, the convict, the outcast, 1886–First, E. C. Ritsher, Beloit College ; second, H. Jean Valjean. But out of the great, deep, loving, sac- H. Russell, Oberlin College. rificing soul of Bienvenu leaped Jean Valjean the man, 1887–First, John H. Finley, Knox College ; second, the citizen, the benefactor. You remember the story, Parke Daniels, Wabash College. how after the bishop saved Jean from the galleys, he 1888–First, R. G. Johnson, De Pauw University ; secspoke to him these simple words : “Go in peace. It is

ond, Harry M. Hyde, Beloit College. your soul I am buying for you, and I withdraw it from 1889–First, Ed. H. Hughes, Wesleyan University ; secthe dark i houghts and from the spirit of perdition, and ond, J. A. Blaisdell, Beloit College. give it to God.” That deed, accompanied by these words,

1890—First, S. W. Naylor, Washburn College ; second, made it possible for this life, which was torn within by all A. C. Douglass, Monmouth College. the sins and vices of the flesh, and oppressed without by 1891–First, Frank Fetter, Indiana University ; second, the evıl conditions of the times, to rise superior to them Guy E. Maxwell, Hamline University. all.

1892–First, Miss E. Jean Nelson, De Pauw University ; That is personality that can stoop and lift fallen man- second, G. H. Geyer, Ohio Wesleyan University. kind; it is to become the greatest force in the evolution 1893—First, A. A. Hopkins, Lake Forest University ; of society. Behold Jean Valjean as he now stands before second, J. H. Kimball, Beloit University. the world, transformed. Up to this time he has only ex- 1894–First, C. F. Wishart, Monmouth College ; second, isted. He now begins to live. The purpose of revenge is L. F. Dimmitt, De Pauw University. now the purpose to save. As he stands there at the 1895–First, Otto A. Hauerbach, Knox College ; second, threshold of his mission, looking out upon the troubled Charles W. Wood, Beloit College. waves of life, this man for the first time in nineteen years weeps. "The man that cannot weep,” says Victor Hugo, A number of these men have fully justified the “cannot see.” Jean sees clearly now. He forgets himself highest expectations of their friends, and have made and strives only to live for others. The bishop dies, but themselves widely known as eloquent speakers at the the influence of his personality lives on.

bar, in the pulpit, in legislative halls, or on educaShow the world a Voltaire, and it will predict a French

cational platforms. There is a current newspaper Revolution. Give to struggling humanity a personality

assertion to the effect that these brilliant and promlike that of Bienvenu, and there is life and salvation even for such a fallen, depraved wretch as Jean Valjean.

ising collegians are the ones of whom nothing is heard in future years.

The facts belie such a It must not be assumed that the orations which judgment. It may be the man who stood third, win the prizes are greatly superior, as pieces of liter- rather than the man that happened to take first ary production, to those which are not so fortunate. honors, who ten years later has gained the higher The disparities—whether in the home contests, the place in the estimation of his fellow citizens. But state competitions, or the final interstate meeting, speaking in general, it is within the bounds of truth between the winners and their disappointed compet- to say that the Western students of the past twentyitors are usually not so wide as to discredit in any five years who have tried diligently to learn the art way the unsuccessful young orators. The following of public speaking, and who have shown the most list is interesting as showing the men and the col- promise and aptitude in their college days, are the leges which have been successful in securing first and ones who have been most successful in the larger and second places in the interstate contests for twenty- harsher competitive struggle of the great world outtwo successive years :

side of college walls.

[graphic][merged small]
« PreviousContinue »