« PreviousContinue »
well as the one always in my hand, in which he had laid down the Temple, Mt. Zion, and the valley between them, across which the arch looks directly, could hardly have doubted or been mistaken with regard to its design. Mr. Catherwood has often told me since, that my account is strictly true, and that he, as well as several other gentlemen with whom he conversed in Jerusalem, regarded and spoke of this monument as the remains of an ancient bridge, that connected the Jewish Temple with Mt. Zion. My declaration, that I could not learn that this monument had been mentioned by any modern traveller, appears under date of April 23d, 1840, and is strictly true. I should have referred to Dr. Robinson's account, which I saw nearly two years afterwards, but for the discrepancy between it and mine, to which, for insufficient reasons it may be, but assuredly not from selfish ends, nor from any unfriendly feelings towards Dr. Robinson, I did not wish to attract attention.
"In my description of the Dead Sea, I borrowed nothing from the Researches.' I might have given Dr. Robinson's valuable account instead of my own, derived from personal observations and inquiries, and from later travellers; and so I might have done, no doubt, to the advantage of my readers, with regard to many other objects. I professedly gave the dimensions of that sea as a conjecture merely, after repeating many discordant and irreconcilable accounts. Had I observed the alleged agreement of my statement with Dr. Robinson's estimate, I suppose I should have avoided the appearance of plagiarism by giving a different number, which would have satisfied my guess about as well. I read this portion of the Researches' without perceiving, that Dr. Robinson's account claims, and no doubt with a measure of justice, to rest on scientific data. I had noted one trigonometrical observation, which seemed to me not to be very satisfactory.
"With regard to the Tower of David, which I saw on my first entrance into Jerusalem, and very frequently afterwards, it being one of the most conspicuous objects in the holy city, my "Travels' contain the results of my own observations, and of my frequent conversations with Mr. Nicolayson and others, from whom I learned, that the monument was usually held to be the Hippicus of Josephus, whose account I also consulted. It is a question again, whether I should have substituted for my own, Dr. Robinson's account, to which mine owes nothing.
"My statement and conjectures about the pool of Bethesda are also objected to, not as being false, but as concurring with Dr. Robinson. A careful perusal of what I wrote on this doubtful topic will show, that I expressed no opinion of my own, but only recounted several contradictory opinions, traditions, and facts, not
one of which was derived from Dr. Robinson, without attempting to reconcile them.
"I erroneously referred to Pococke as my authority for what I understood to be an old tradition, as well as a prevalent opinion at Jerusalem, in regard to the subterranean connexion between the fountains concealed by Hezekiah and those of the Virgin and Siloam. I should have quoted Richardson, who says, that the pool called the fountain of the Stairs, the fountain of the Virgin, as I understood the passage, -'receives a strong current of water by a subterraneous passage, cut in the north side of Mount Zion, which seems as if it came by a conduit cut through the rock, from the pool of Hezekiah, on the west side of the city.' This statement, which I had in my hand, taken in connexion with what was told me by Mr. Lanneau and others, as reported in my 'Travels,' and the Scriptural accounts, which I also carefully consulted on the spot, was the basis, and is indeed the substance, of the opinions and conjectures which I ventured to offer to my readers on this point.
"I will only add, with regard to the several topics selected by the Reviewer for animadversion, that I have not knowingly derived either facts, arguments, or opinions from Dr. Robinson. What his views were on these points I had never an intimation, until I read the Researches' in 1842. I have not since referred to that able and learned work; but I had not supposed, that it laid claim to original discovery in connexion with these topics, except in the case of the ancient arch. My companions in the Desert and in Palestine, I think, would all certify, that I worked hard and examined every thing for myself. Every attentive reader will perceive, that I take all proper occasions to do justice to Dr. Robinson's excellent volumes. I certainly have seen no reasons for changing my opinions about the identity of the Holy Sepulchre; but my language on that subject was unguarded, if it led the Reviewer to think, that it was from superstitious reverence, I stood on my knees and had a taper in my hand,' in examining the place of the Cross. The room was dark, and this, or some more lowly, attitude was necessary for the attainment of my object. "STEPHEN OLIN.
"November 30th, 1843.”
We are quite willing to place Dr. Olin's statement before our readers, leaving it for them to judge, after comparing those passages from the two works to which reference was made in our article, how far the explanation is a satisfactory one. We have no room for any other remarks at this time, but as there are some points in Dr. Olin's letter which require more particular comment, it is possible that we may return to the subject in another Number.
QUARTERLY LIST OF NEW PUBLICATIONS.
The American Agriculturist's Almanac for 1844. By A. B. Allen, Editor of “The American Agriculturist." New York: J. Winchester. 8vo. pp. 62.
The Farmer's Encyclopedia and Dictionary of Rural Affairs. By Cuthbert W. Johnson, Esq., F. R. S. Adapted to the United States, by Gouverneur Emerson. Philadelphia: Carey & Hart. 8vo. pp.
The Cultivator's Almanac, or Rural Calendar for the Year 1844. By Willis Gaylord and Luther Tucker. New York: M. H. Newman. 12mo. pp. 32.
The Gift; a Christmas and New Year's Present. M DCCC XLIV. Philadelphia: Carey & Hart. 8vo. pp. 296.
The New York State Register, for 1843. Containing an Almanac, Civil Divisions, and Census of the State, with Political, Statistical, and other Information. Edited by O. L. Holley. Albany: J. Disturnell. 12mo. pp. 432.
The American Almanac, and Repository of Useful Knowledge, for the Year 1844. Boston: David H. Williams. 12mo. pp. 342. The United States Almanac; or Complete Ephemeris, for the Year 1844. Philadelphia: E. H. Butler. 12mo. pp. 316.
Statistical Almanac for the Year 1844, by Edward Delius. Philadelphia: Carey & Hart. 32mo. pp. 240.
Friendship's Offering, and Winter's Wreath. A Christmas and New Year's Present for M DCCC XLIV. Boston: Lewis & Sampson. 12mo. pp. 320.
The Drawing Room Annual; a Present for all Seasons. Philadelphia: Lindsay & Blakiston. 4to. pp. 64.
The Rose: or Affection's Gift for 1844. Edited by Emily Marshall. Illustrated with ten highly finished Steel Engravings. New York: D. Appleton & Co. 12mo. pp. 256.
The Opal; a Pure Gift for the Holydays. With nine Illustrations, by J. G. Chapman. Riker. 12mo. pp. 264.
Edited by N. P. Willis.
Diary for 1844; or Daily Register, for the Use of Private Families, and Persons of Business. Harrisburg, Pa.: Hickok & Cantine. 12mo. pp. 142.
The Literary Souvenir; a Christmas and New Year's Present for VOL. LVIII. —No. 122. 33
1844. pp. 252.
With ten Engravings. Philadelphia: Carey & Hart. 12mo.
The Annualette. A Christmas and New Year's Gift for 1844. Edited by a Lady. Boston: T. H. Carter & Co. 12mo. pp. 142.
The Boy's and Girl's Annual; a Christmas and New Year's Present for 1844. Boston: T. H. Carter & Co. 12mo. pp. 160.
Youth's Keepsake, and Christmas and New Year's Gift for Young People. Boston: T. H. Carter & Co. 12mo. pp. 206.
The Little Keepsake, for 1844. Edited by Mrs. S. Colman. Boston: T. H. Carter & Co. 24mo. pp. 107.
The Little Gift, for 1844. Edited by Mrs. S. Colman. Boston: T. H. Carter & Co. 24mo. pp. 107.
The Rose of Sharon; a Religious Souvenir, for M DCCC XLIV. Edited by Miss Sarah C. Edgarton. Boston: A. Tompkins & B. B. Mussey. 12mo. pp. 304.
A Biographical Sketch of Colonel Richard M. Johnson, of Kentucky. By a Kentuckian. New York: Saxton & Miles. 8vo. pp. 46.
Memoir of Mrs Anna Maria Morrison, of the North India Mission. By E. J. Richards. New York: M. W. Dodd. 12mo. pp. 176.
Memoir of Timothy W. Lester, or Eminent Piety the Great Qualification for Usefulness. By Isaac C. Beach. New York: M. W. Dodd. 24mo. pp. 149.
Life of Andrew Jackson, Private, Military, and Civil. With Illustrations. By Amos Kendall. Part I. New York: Harper & Brothers. 8vo. pp. 48.
American Biography. By Jeremy Belknap, D. D.; with Additions and Notes by F. M. Hubbard. New York: Harper & Brothers. 3 vols. 18mo.
Penmanship, Theoretical and Practical, Illustrated and Explained. By B. F. Foster. Boston: Benjamin Perkins. 12mo. pp. 87.
German Reader for Beginners. Compiled by Bernard Rölker, Instructor in Harvard University. Boston: James Munroe & Co. 12mo. pp. 324.
The Elements of Astronomy; designed as an Introduction to the Study. Prepared and published for Mrs. John Sharp Lawrence's School. New York: John S. Taylor & Co. 12mo. pp. 82.
A French Granımar; containing, besides the Rules of the Language, a Complete Treatise on Prepositions. By Count de Laporte, Teacher of the French Language in Boston. Boston: Otis, Broaders, & Co. 12mo. pp. 782.
Most of the text books in common use among us at the present day for instruction in French are designed only for beginners, and contain but a brief and imperfect view of the grammatical peculiarities of the language. A more full and elaborate treatise was needed for occasional reference by those who had made some progress in the study, and for constant use by all who aimed at a perfect mastery of the subject. In the large and hand
somely executed volume now before us, Count de Laporte, a successful teacher in Boston, has endeavoured to supply this want, and, so far as we have had opportunity to examine the work, it appears to be executed with great care, judgment, and fidelity. The difficult subjects of the proper use of prepositions, and the regimen of verbs, are treated at great length, and in a very lucid and satisfactory manner. Examples are spread upon the page in great abundance, taken mostly from authors in high repute, and the minute and critical examination of them, though better adapted, perhaps, for a French treatise upon rhetoric, than for a manual to be used by foreigners in the acquisition of the language, is well calculated to give precision to the ideas of the student, and to impart some valuable information respecting the philosophy of language in general. But little is said on the subject of pronunciation, for the very satisfactory reason mentioned in the Preface, that if the pupil has a teacher, he will learn it by the ear; if he has not, the attempt to gain any correct knowledge of the peculiarities of French as a spoken language is hopeless. The Syntax is not treated separately in this grammar, the rules for the syntactical arrangement and construction of words being presented in connexion with what is said on the use of the different parts of speech. This is an innovation on the common method, but we are inclined to think that it is a judicious one. The volume contains no exercises for writing French, being already of great size without the introduction of such matter; but the author mentions his intention to publish another work, which will supply this deficiency.
We commend the book to the attention both of pupils and instructers in French, as we believe there are few among them who will not be benefited by the attentive perusal of it.
Historical Notes of the American Colonies and Revolution, from 1754 to 1775. By William Griffith. Burlington, N. J.: Joseph L. Powell. 8vo. pp. 300.
The Every Day Book of History and Chronology; embracing the Anniversaries of Memorable Persons and Events, in every Period and State of the World. By Joel Munsell. Albany: Erastus H. Pease. 2 vols. 12mo. pp. 428 and 412.
The History of the Puritans, or Protestant Non-Conformists; from the Reformation in 1517, to the Revolution in 1688. By Daniel Neal, M. A. Reprinted from the Text of Dr. Toulmin's Edition. Revised, corrected, and enlarged, by John O. Choules, M. A. New York: Harper & Brothers. 8vo. pp. 144.
The Saint Nicholas Gift, for Little Boys and Girls.
The Child's Gem. A Holyday Gift.
Edited by Mrs. S. Colman.
The Law of Nisi Prius, Evidence in Civil Actions, and Arbitrations and Awards. By Archibald John Stephens. With Notes, and References to the latest American Decisions, by George Stanwood. Philadelphia: Carey & Hart. 8vo. pp. 960.
A Discourse on the Study of the Law of Nature and Nations,