OF

CASES AT LAW AND IN EQUITY

DETERMINED BY THE

SUPREME COURT

OF THE

STATE OF IOWA

JANUARY TERM, 1913.

BY

W. W. CORNWALL

REPORTER

VOLUME XLII.

BEING VOLUME CLIX OF THE SERIES.

CHICAGO, ILLINOIS:

T. H. FLOOD & CO., PUBLISHERS,

Entered according to act of Congress in the year 1914, for the

State of Iowa,

BY WILLIAM S. ALLEN, SECRETARY OF STATE.

In the office of the Librarian of Congress, Washington, D. C.

AN 5 1915

FROM WHICH APPEALS MAY BE TAKEN TO THE SUPREME COURT.

DISTRICT COURTS.

First District-WILLIAM S. HAMILTON, Ft. Madison; HENRY Bank, Jr.,
Keokuk.
Second District--D. M. ANDERSON, Albia; F. W. EICHELBERGER, Bloom-
field; F. M. HUNTER, Ottumwa; C. W. VERMILION, Centerville.
Third District-THOMAS L. MAXWELL, Creston; HIRAM K. EVANS,

Corydon.

Fourth District-DAVID MOULD, Sioux City; GEORGE JEPSON, Sioux City; J. F. OLIVER, Onawa.

Fifth District-LORIN N. HAYS, Knoxville; J. H. APPLEGATE, Guthrie Center; WILLIAM H. FAHEY, Perry.

Sixth District-K. E. WILLCOCKSON, Sigourney; JOHN F. TALBOTT, Brooklyn; HENRY SELWOLD, Newton.

Seventh District-ARTHUR P. BARKER, Clinton; A. J. HOUSE, Maquoketa; L. J. HORAN, Muscatine; WILLIAM THEOPHILUS, Davenport; MAURICE DONEGAN, Davenport.

Eighth District-RALPH P. HOWELL, Iowa City.

Ninth District-LAWRENCE DE GRAFF, Des Moines; HUGH BRENNAN,
Des Moines; W. H. MCHENRY, Des Moines; CHARLES S. BRAD-
SHAW,
Des Moines, and CHARLES A. DUDLEY, Des Moines.
Tenth District-GEORGE W. DUNHAM, Manchester; FRANKLIN C. PLATT,
Waterloo; CHARLES W. MULLEN, Waterloo.

Eleventh District-R. M. WRIGHT, Ft. Dodge; C. E. ALBROOK, Eldora;
C. G. LEE, Ames.

Twelfth District-MILLARD F. EDWARDS, Parkersburg; C. H. KELLEY, Forest City; J. J. CLARK, Mason City.

Thirteenth District-L. E. FELLOWS, Lansing; WILLIAM G. SPRINGER, New Hampton.

Fourteenth District-D. F. COYLE, Humboldt; N. J. LEE, Estherville. Fifteenth District-A. B. THORNELL, Sidney; EUGENE B. WOODRUFF, Glenwood; ORVILLE D. WHEELER, Council Bluffs; THOMAS Arthur, Logan; JOSEPH B. ROCKAFELLOW, Atlantic.

Sixteenth District-F. M. PowERS, Carroll; M. E. HUTCHINSON, Lake City.

Seventeenth District-C. B. BRADSHAW, Toledo; CLARENCE NICHOLS,

Vinton.

Eighteenth District-W. N. TREICHLER, Tipton; F. O. ELLISON, Anamosa; MILO P. SMITH, Cedar Rapids.

Nineteenth District-ROBERT BONSON, Dubuque; JOHN W. KINTZINGER,

Dubuque.

Twentieth District—JAMES D. SMYTH, Burlington; OSCAR HALE, Wapello. Twenty-first District-W. D. BOIES, Sheldon; WM. HUTCHINSON, Alton. SUPERIOR COURTS.

Cedar Rapids-CHARLES B. ROBBINS.

Council Bluffs-S. B. SNYDER.
Grinnell-PAUL G. NORRIS.

Keokuk-W. L. MCNAMARA,

Oelwein-EUGENE J. O'CONNOR.
Perry-JOHN SHORTLEY.

Shenandoah-GEO. H. CASTLE.