Page images
PDF
EPUB

Robertson pupils, and the deep reflexes were not entirely gone. Remained here six months. Dr. Trimble then made a Wasserman. Positive. Then 606 given intramuscularly. Made more rapid improvement on 606. After taking specific treatment then for a few months he went to Hot Springs, Arkansas, and had 606 again. The question here, it seems to me is, whether this cord lesion is due to pressure on a syphilitic spine, or one with a tubercular involvement.

DISCUSSION.

DR. ROBINSON: I first saw this patient three years ago. Comparing his condition then to what it is now I am certainly pleased with the outcome of the case. He then had total loss of function below the point of the lesion in spine. He now shows good motor and sensory action. There is some sclerosis, yet that in all probability will not recover. The question is, what is it? The difficulty is in finding the cause, or just what is wrong. There are indications of tubercule. The X-ray showed breaking down of the vertebra,and a condition of pressure. The tuberculin test was positive. We made no Wasserman. Dr. Welch found a positive Wasserman, and under mercurial and other anti-luetic treatment he has made this recovery. I am not satisfied as to what the condition was. I admit I am puzzled as to what the lesion was, unless it was a gummatous condition.

DR. SKOOG: Summing up the history here, I

would not have suspected a tubercular lesion. To me it looks like syphilis. In X-ray findings it is so easy to fall in error in translating from skiagrams, and you cannot differentiate a tubercular process in that way from a gumma. In this man the reflexes of the lower extremities are markedly increased, and there is ankle clonus of the left ankle. Achilles reflexes are gone. His pupils are large, but equal, but do not react promptly to light. The pains this man has are probably analogous to the root pains of tabes. This case is not yet free from active processes, and should be treated as such. This man is yet to be thoroughly examined, for a complete clinical neurological report has not been made on this

case.

DR. HILL: I am curious to know what has happened to the X-ray plates referred to in connection with this case. If they showed so much why are they not offered in evidence? My observation has been in relation to such cases, that it is easy to find something wrong with the spine if the spine lesion is producing symptoms such as we have here.

DR. WELCH (closing): The diagnosis of tubercular spine in this case was made from the family history plus the laboratory findings, and X-ray. Dr. Scott assured us the picture showed a condition of breaking down of the bodies of the vertebrae, that we supposed to be pressing on the cord, and producing paralysis, so we kept him in bed and later sent him to New Mexico. On return, with positive Wasserman, our ideas began to change, we then thought of other possibilities. My diagnosis of syphilis is based on the results of the treatment that helped him so much.

T

PRESENTATION OF A CASE OF HERPES OF THE CORNEA.
J. S. Lichtenberg, M. D., Kansas City, Mo.

HIS young man is 27 years of age. Two years ago I saw him in this condition, and now he presents himself, 17th of March last, right cornea covered with small vesicles. These disappeared in a few days, and another crop came.

Herpes of the cornea is divided by Weeks in three forms, neuralgic, herpetic and febrile. This is a mixture of the neuralgic and herpetic forms. The patient had an eruption on the lips and face at the same time.

Some authorities connect this condition with plasmodium in the blood. Dr. R. H. Meade made a blood examination here and found no plasmodium. There was in this patient a slight lymphocytosis. I gave Fowler's solution, and Dr. Meade reinforced this with cacodylate of soda, hypodermically, and this treatment helped very much. These cases are very rare. I have seen very few, perhaps half a dozen. This is as I call it, a herpetic and neuralgic type. It is a question here if the Wasserman ganglion is involved. Except for the scars we see here, he has made a good recovery.

DISCUSSION.

DR. BELLOWS: In presenting this case Dr. Lichtenberg has covered the important things of this condition. I can add little. They are very uncommon. One thing not mentioned is the severe pain a patient suffers in this condition. In the diagnosis one might be inclined to call this a simple ulceration of the cornea. I saw a once that went on to the rapid destruction of the cornea. The doctor is to be congratulated on his results in this case.

case

DR. FRANK HALL: The question of lymphocytosis in this relating is interesting. We have lymphocytosis appearing in the course of a lot of infectious intoxications. The most typical is influenza. It has a peculiar capacity of increasing the lymphocytes and decreasing the mononuclear leucocytes. This has been explained, that there are certain substances stimulating the formation of these cells, with reduction of the others, as we see in trichina. The blood here is filled with eosinophiles, because of a certain stimulation to form these cells. In herpes zoster I have examined many cases and they do have lymphocytosis. The last case I had showed 21,000 leucocytes, 81 per cent large and small lymphocytes. This patient here, undoubtedly has had some infectious trouble, and the organism undoubtedly was absorbed by some of the nerve nuclei, and resulted in an inflammation of the ganglia supplying the cornea, and the nerve terminations acted wrongly, and formed these vesicles on the cornea.

These things are to be looked on as intoxications. In these cases unaccompanied by temperature we look for a metabolic source of the toxin. I have seen cases of vesicular eruptions due to absorption from infectious urine. In such cases thorough cleansing of the bowels will stop these eruptions. These things should be viewed as a metabolic disturbance, or infective.

S. GROVER BURNETT: This is a toxic neuritis. It is a neuritis severing the peripheral nerve terminals from the trophic cell influence. For this reason the periphery is the seat hf the acute trophic changes as pictured in the vesicles and the slight or extensive necrotic change which may follow the breaking of the vesicles. The early pelplexing symptom is pain. The relief of this pain is difficult.

Drs. Lichtenberg and Bellows have hinted at this problem. Ordinarily narcotics do not meet the indication. After bitter experience I have learned to meet this issue with dram doses of fluid extract of ergot. It relieves the early, unbearable pain and tends to shorten the iuflammatory process. This means much when we remember that vesicles forming over the iris, means resulting scar tissue and destroyed vision.

DR. LICHTENBERG (closing): I wish to thank the gentlemen for the discussion of this case. I have nothing to say in closing, but will add to what I have already said, that the scarring of the cornea here perhaps is due to my medication. I cauterized here with iodin and carbolic acid.

A TOAST: "ST. JOSEPH; ITS FUTURE as a medICAL CENTER.'
Daniel Morton, M. D., St. Joseph, Mo.
Mr. Toastmaster, Our Honored Guests and
Fellow Members:

Our society is to be congratulated upon this, the tenth annual, banquet, marking as it does, ten years of existence, occupied with the laudable objects for which this organization was created. During the past year four agencies have been inaugurated in St. Joseph that should be matters of great satisfaction to us, as members of the medical profession."

Through the agency of this society, a medical journal club has been created and the files of its journals placed in the public library. This assures for each physician practicing in St. Joseph, the best current medical literature.

This society organized the movement for the prevention of tuberculosis three years ago.

One month ago the people of this community placed the seal of approval upon this work by establishing under the law the Buchanan County Tuberculosis District, and the Governor of the State has appointed the Board of Commissioners. Thus is assured an efficient campaign against the great white plague, all the forces of society being brought into relation thereto.

[ocr errors]

faithful, and yet the bequest fail of its purpose, unless the medical service be efficient. A Visiting Nurse Association has been formed within the year. It is my opinion that the influence of this organization will be far-reaching in putting medical social service in St. Joseph upon a scientific and sociologic basis. We should encourage in every possible manner this most important movement, for as a result of its work will come in the years that lie before us firsthand knowledge of medico-social conditions upon which will be based the agencies for their cure. These are events upon which we may justly felicitate ourselves at such a time as this, when we gather to review the past and to look forward to the future.

I have been asked to speak to the subject, "St. Joseph; Its Future as a Medical Centre." It may be well at the beginning to be sure that we have a uniform conception of what constitutes a medical center. A medical center is a resort for those physically disabled where the latest approved methods of science are applied for the relief of injury and disease. There are many resorts for the physically disabled that are not medical centers. The mere flocking of people to any point for relief does not constitute such a point a medical center. It is the application of the latest scientific methods of relief that is the distinguishing characteristic.

The announcement of the bequest of Mr.
C. W. Noyes for the founding and main-
taining of a hospital is another event of
this year that has given our society great
satisfaction. While it cannot be said that
our society originated this bequest, it no
doubt is true that the bequest would never
have been made had not the noble founder
reposed faith and confidence in the profes-
sion of this city. In the ultimate analysis,
the successful consummation of the bequest
depends upon whether or not the medical
profession render efficient service as its con-
tribution to the enterprise. The donor
may be generous, the trustees may be
*Delivered at Tenth Annual Banquet, Buchanan County Medical Society. St. Joseph, Mo., December 21, 1912.

Not only will such a resort attract the sick and afflicted to it, but, far more important, there will radiate from it influences which prevent disease and promote health and physical efficiency. This is the true conception of a medical center. Any community aspiring to become such a medical center must comply with certain well-known essential conditions. The med. ical profession must be imbued with the scientific and social spirit. The medical

profession must be well organized. The medical service must be well organized.

From the viewpoint of the physician the practice of medicine has three aspects, the scientific, the social, the commercial.

It is the glory of our profession that we practice "scientific medicine," that we base our professional work upon scientific facts evolved by the method of inductive philosophy and experimental research. Other methods of practice are necessarily sectarian basing their work upon historic dogmas. This is the opposite of scientific method; it is most unscientific. Scientific medicine says that "one should not teach dogmas, on the contrary, every utterance must, be put to the proof. One should not train disciples but form observers, one must teach and work in the spirit of natural science" (Johannes Orth). This is our declaration This is our declaration of scientific faith.

There was a time when the duty of the physician ended with his personal ministrations to his patient. That day has passed never to return. In addition to these personal ministrations and over and beyond them, the advance of knowledge concerning health and sanitation has placed the doctor in the position of service not only to the individual but to the community as a collection of individuals, to society if you please. More and more will the doctor become a factor in the working out of all those social problems of community life connected with the health and efficiency of society. Tuberculosis, housing, women in industry, infectious disease, intemperance, insanity, eugenics and many others are all social problems which society must solve but each is a medical problem, and none of them will be solved until the way is pointed out by the medical profession. The social duty of the physician therefore has been greatly enlarged so that his responsibility lies not only with the individual but with the community as well. Into this larger field of work for the new humanity our profession is but just entering. The prevention of disease is the highest ideal of the medical profession. This is a social duty and more important than any other function we perform. The time is gone when the medical profession can hold itself aloof from the rest of the community. Doctors must engage in all the activities of modern civic life. In this way only will our profession be able to direct and mold the influences that make for better medical service for poor and rich alike. German physicians have learned this lesson and American physicians are learning it. It is to be regretted that this society is not repre

sented upon our Commerce Club Directory. It is my belief that the best interests of the profession and of the community require such representation year after year.

In order to practice however, and perform these scientific and social functions doctors must live. How to get that living has been the problem of the ages. In days of old, the honorarium was the established custom. In "Journeys in Diverse Places," Ambrose Pare states that he treated M. le. Marquis d. Auret who suffered from a gunshot wound near the knee with fracture of the bone, and that after his patient's recov ery, he made me a handsome present of great value and sent me back with the steward and two pages to my house in Paris." After the honorarium came the system now in vogue by which varying charges are made according to the professional service rendered. These systems have been the natural outgrowth of individualistic practice. But times change and we change with them and now that the practice of medicine has become a social function the state will become the paymaster of the doctor more and more and the individual less and less. In the Journal of the American Medical Association of November 23d, last, under the title "Socializing the British Medical Profession" the following edi torial comments are made in speaking of the so-called Insurance Act: "If we are not mistaken this law marks the beginning of the end of the old system of the individual practice of medicine and of the old relationship between patient and physician, the beginning of a new era, both for society and for physicians. It provides for noth. ing less than an assumption on the part of the government of the responsibility of providing proper medical care for citizens who are financially unable to secure it for themselves." These are startling statements and mean nothing more than an economic revolution for the medical profession. It is a true saying that "the practice of medicine is the noblest of professions and the meanest of trades." There can be no question that the fee system has had a commercializing effect upon the profession, a tendency to make it a trade, to make it a mere means for obtaining a livelihood. But whether it comes from honorarium or fee or government salary, some way will be found to provide a living for the true physician. But it will be a living wage and not a fortune. The practice of medicine is not a vocation suitable for the accumulation of a fortune. It is improper to enter it with this end in view. The rewards are a competency only, the respect of the com

[ocr errors]

munity and the opportunity for service to humanity.

According to the emphasis which every doctor places upon the scientific, social or commercial aspect of practice he measures up to or falls short of the ideal physician. The first and fundamental necessity for a medical center, is a group of physicians thoroughly imbued with the scientific and social spirit, men who love the work for its own sake and recognize the social responsibility it entails and with whom the commercial equation is subordinate to the other two.

The subdivision of the profession into specialties is a natural and inevitable consequence of the advance in scientific and medical knowledge. It is to be regretted that St. Joseph physicians have not specialized more. To become an efficient organized body capable of good team work this will be necessary and unless it is done we cannot hope to maintain in the future, our status as a medical center. The idea of specialism as the highest type of medical efficiency has very properly become rooted in the mind of the public, and if St. Joseph does not meet this demand for specially trained physicians, the public will go elsewhere to satisfy it. The legitimate specialties are not very numerous and are well represented by the sections of the American Medical Association. I may mention internal medicine, diseases of children, tuberculosis, nervous and mental diseases, general surgery, gynecology with abdominal surgery, obstetrics, orthopedic

surgery,

genito-urinary surgery, rectal surgery. These specialties could be successfully practiced in St. Joseph. I do not think it necessary to mention diseases of the eye, ear, nose and throat, for these specialties are now well established here. But the subdivision of professional work could now be easily made along the lines of the specialties mentioned, with every possible advantage to both doctor and public. It is rapidly becoming easier to build up a practice as a specialist than as a general practitioner, and when once accomplished the service rendered by the physician is more efficient and the remuneration better. subdivision of practice has a good effect upon the profession itself as it makes it possible for cooperation between physicians where formerly existed competition. this way is secured a profession working together instead of at cross purposes, efficient team work, resulting in good for all. Today the practice of medicine consists of cooperation between the various departments of a highly organized profession,

The

In

each department thereof dependent in some wise upon every other department, if the highest results are attained in the application of human knowledge to the relief of human suffering. Whatever local conditions existed in the past to prevent this subdivision have now been dispelled, and a failure to conform to this essential requirement for efficient medical organization will prove suicidal. This principle must be recognized and acted upon by our profession for St. Joseph cannot hope to maintain in the future her standing as a medical center if the profession remains a group of general practitioners only.

Among the agencies of organized medical service that go to make a medical center none stand higher than the clinical and research laboratory.

It is

The debt that medicine owes to general science is tremendous. Before the revival of knowledge on a scientific basis, medicine was little better than a mass of empiricism, dogmatism and mysticism. Progress under such conditions was hopeless and finally came from the outside and not from the inside. It was by the application of the scientific method of experimental research that our profession was placed upon a scientific basis. We should never forget this, for it is only by the continuation of this method that we can hope to progress still further. Unless we use the scientific facts now known to be useful in the prevention and relief of disease we are still unscientific physicians, practicing empiricism. through the medical laboratory that these facts are now made avialable for us in the daily practice of medicine. daily practice of medicine. I am sure that there can be no argument over the statement that our laboratory facilities in St. Joseph are inadequate. The medical profession itself may be ideal, the hospital facilities may be all that is desired and yet our practice still remain unscientific and incomplete without the facilities afforded by a medical laboratory. This is a fundamental necessity, upon which the whole superstructure of scientific practice is built, it matters not whether that practice is in hospital, in home, in city, in town, in country. It is to the credit of this society that it has recognized this fact and appointed a standing Medical Laboratory Committee to promote the enterprise in St. Joseph. Without adequate medical laboratory facilities St. Joseph can never hope to become a medical center. It is the most essential of all the agencies required. One million people are looking to the medical profession of St. Joseph and its tributary country to give to them all the aid known

to medical science. By way of encouragement we should remember that the financing of medical laboratories is much easier of accomplishment than of hospitals. The initial cost is not nearly so great and the administration is simpler and less complicated. A small per cent only of the total investment need be tied up in buildings and equipment. By far the larger part may become endowment, and thus be constantly making the benefits of the laboratory available for the sick.

The two general hospitals now existing, one protestant, one catholic, fully occupy the field of general hospital work and it would seem that the addition of another general hospital working in the same field is not at this time needed. It would act as competitor to those now here and by dividing the work into small portions, weaken the existing institutions. The present in stitutions are general not special hospitals, and should be strengthened in every possible manner, by endowment, by donation, by church support, by professional support, by support of the business men and by the moral support of the entire city. In the building up of a hospital system for any community the general hospital comes first. In this direction our need is to strengthen what we have, rather than to multiply their number. It would seem that St. Joseph protestanism should learn from the mistakes of other communities that is better to concentrate its forces upon one general hospital, and to make it capable of doing the work intended, rather than to create several general hospitals, each one a denominational institution, inadequately equipped, endowed and supported, and therefore incapable of doing the intended work efficiently. These statements apply to general hospitals only and not to special hospitals.

In the field of Special Hospitals there is opportunity for the utilization of all the forces and finances that are likely to be available in the years that are to come. Here there need be no over-lapping but each hospital may be made to fill a useful place in the general hospital scheme of organization.

Our greatest need in medical specialism is that of emphasizing the importance of internal medicine. Internal medicine is the mother, and therefore the greatest of all the specialties. Where it is neglected well balanced well rounded service is impossible. In St. Joseph we have been running toward surgery and internal medicine has rather been pushed into the back-ground. It should be placed in its

position of first importance. We need practitioners who are internists only, who do no surgery at all. We need a special hospital for internal medicine only, or our general hospitals should increase their usefullness by dividing the service into a medical and surgical side, with a medical pavilion separate from the surgical pavilion. The practice of medicine as distinguished from surgery needs to be emphasized in this way. We must get down to this basic principle of medical organization and provide adequate facilities for the development of internal medicine. It is the keystone in the arch of practice that holds together all departments in a completed whole.

Obstetrics is another slighted branch of practice among us. It is certainly a gratifying sign of the times that our presidentelect has established a private maternity hospital and is devoting himself to that branch of practice. He will have the honor of being the first practitioner of our city to establish obstetrics as a distinct specialty in our midst. But this is in the field of private endeavor only. There is need of an endowed public maternity hospital, for those who cannot pay, for those who can pay moderate compensation, for those who can pay a full compensation. Obstet. rics is a surgical specialty and no branch of surgery can be practiced in the home as well as in a hospital equipped for surgical work. Ideally it should not be done in connection with other surgical work of a septic nature such as is necessarily found in general hospitals. Ideally it should not be done in association with hospitals for men for reasons of delicacy and modesty. These reasons are all-powerful, and point the way to the Obstetric Hospital as a separate and special hospital.

These same reasons account for the present day disposition on the part of any community to avail itself of the facilities of obstetric hospitals wherever established. The day is not far distant when every woman, who has the choice, will prefer the obstetric hospital for the place of her confinement. Humanity owes it to her that at such a time she should have the best aid that science can give. Our profession renders no service more sacred than that of attendance upon the birth of the generations of humanity. The influence of such a hospital could be made to reach the homes of the lowliest by the establishment of an out-door department with visiting nurses. What a benediction such a work would be to every child-bearing woman in this community.

A Children's Hospital would fill an unoccupied place, as our medical service is at

« PreviousContinue »