Reviews

User reviews

User Review - Flag as inappropriate

An overall excellent book on the strategy, politics, and major events of the Napoleonic Wars. Esdaile is careful not to delve too deep into individual battles whose historical analysis as he states has been endlessly reviewed but focusing on the themes, general developments, and personalities involved at the time. It is a critical history that challenges the arguments of whom he deems "apologists" of Napoleon by noting Napoleon's seemingly endless ambition for victory that eventually doomed his empire to a massive alliance dedicated to destroying him. Of great benefit to the historical reader is that Esdaile rightly points out his avoidance of succumbing to the "great man" theory of history involving important figures like Napoleon, Napoleon is important but he is not the centre of all the causes and effects of the war. Esdaille gives important analysis of other figures such as the emperors of Russia and Austria, the diplomats, lobbyists such as Polish nationalists, and the situations facing soldiers on the move.
The book is generally a bit dry, the reader will not find any of the stories of sensuous relations involving Napoleon as in other books involving him, as it is focused on the more sober issues of Napoleon's career as a military commander and head of state. It may be criticized for focusing too much of the blame of the wars and France's failure to win on Napoleon's vain ambitious behaviour. Also the density of information covered in each page means that this book is best for an advanced reader or a reader who is very interested in this topic, while it may be difficult for the casual reader who does not have background in the topics described in the book. But overall the detail of this book provides excellent insight into the Napoleonic Wars.
 

All reviews - 2
5 stars - 0
3 stars - 0
2 stars - 0
1 star - 0
Unrated - 0

All reviews - 2
Editorial reviews - 0

All reviews - 2