Opposed to Both Propositions, 304.

Ought to Be Adopted, 365.

Out of Politics, 80.

Party Suicide, 216.

Paying a Heavy Penalty, 139.

"Perfidy" Outcries, 351.

Petty Cheese-Paring Economy, 305.

Piecemeal Revision and the Farmers, 47.

Plain Truth About the Proposed Reciprocity
Agreement, 102.

Playing Politics, 289.

Political Consideration, 305.

"Predigested" Tariff Tinkering, 338.
Preparing to Smash Protection, 45.

President Taft's Reciprocity Message, 216.
Presidential "Logrolling," 352.

Protection Is a Unit or a Cipher, 135.
Protection Is Doomed-If: 350.

Protection to South American Trade, 34.
Protectionism in Iowa, 328.

Protest of North Dakota Farmers, 219.
Provides Substantially for Free-Trade, 105.

Purely a Question of Purchasing Power, 218.
Queer Type of Loyalty, 305.
Questions to Be Considered, 377.

Ragtime and Crazy-Quilt Politics, 231.
Reasonable Prices, 61.

"Reciprocity" and the Farmers' Free List,
228.

Reciprocity Troubles, 35.

Refused to Indorse It, 152.

Reported Without Recommendation, 353.
"Result: Depression,'

377.

Reversal of the American Policy of Non-
Discrimination, 78.

Sad Predicament of "Taft Senators," 365.
Secret Negotiations, 350.

Secretary Wilson's Change of Front, 105.
"Selfishness of the Few?" 377.

Senate Hearings, 269.

Senator Lippitt of Rhode Island, 46.

Senator Smoot on Piecemeal Revision, 59.
Senator Young's Consistent Stand, 58.
Senator Young's Wise Utterance, 21.
Senseless Objections, 32.

Should Be Submitted to the People, 153.

Should Vote Against It, 93.

Simple and Easy, 103.

Simply Silly, 218.

Sound Democratic Tactics, 105.

Souphouse Reciprocity, 266.

Southern Farmers Oppose It, 364.

Spot It and Resent It, 154.

Standing by Taft, 291.

Still Chasing the Reciprocity Rainbow, 20.

Still Harping on "Artificial Barriers,' 267.
Strange Bedfellows, 114.

Strictly Partisan, 92.

Strong Reason for a Recess, 316.

Subversive of the Principle of Protection and
Fair Play, 79.

Suggested Inquiries in the "Investigation" of
the Tariff Board, 291.

Supported Through Ignorance, 364.

Taft and McKinley: A Contrast, 363.

Taft and Tariff Agitation, 352.

Taft Sentiment in Kansas, 352.

Taft's "Chinese Wall" and "Too Much Pro-

tection" Talk, 374.

Take a Recess, 391.

Tariff and Politics, 45.

Tariff Board Extravagance, 290.

Tariff Board Matters, 127.

Tariff Commission Bill in Doubt, 35.

Tariff League Gives Reasons for Opposing
Canadian Agreement, 92.

Tariff Legislation, 18.

Tariff Revision by an Under-Secretary, 326.
That Artificial Wall, 141.

That Monstrous Majority Report, 129.

That "Popular" Scheme, 218.

That's What It Is For, 81.

The Angry Voice of the Farmer, 177.

The Answer of the Farmers, 199.

The Balance of Power, 219.

The British Preferential Still Stands, 229.

The Burning Question, 375.

The Canadian Magnet, 268.

The Case of Senator Lodge, 6.

The Dinner to William Whitman, 268.

The Discreditable Record of Leading Ameri-
can Newspapers, 314.

The Economic Results of Free-Trade in Farm
Products, 246.

The Farmers and the Tariff Board, 197.
The Farmers Are Now Talking, 152.

The Farmer's Point of View, 304.

The Free-Trade Programme in Congress, 230.

The Free Raw Material Theory, 36.

The Late Henry M. Steel, 80.

The League and the Grangers, 340.

The Limit in Addled Politics, 90.

The Longworth Bill, 23.

The McKinley Idea of Reciprocity. 103.

The Main Tenet of Republicansism, 129.

The Massachusetts Idea, 230.

The Minnesota Petition, 365.

The National Welfare, 317.

The New Tariff and Foreign Trade, 32.
The Omnibus and the Baby Carriage, 58.
The President Was Not Tricked, 219.
The President's Mistake, 198.
The Reign of Shoddy, 18.

The Senate and the Canadian Agreement, 327.
The Senate Committee on Finance, 290.
The Taft-Democratic Free-Trade Bill in the
House, 244.

The Workout of Roosevelt "Reciprocity," 363.
The "23" 303.

They Will Better the Instruction, 116.

They Will Know More, 290.
"Traditional Grangers," 329.

Tribute to William Whitman, 231.
Trying to Cobdenize This Country, 129.
Unanimous for Canadian Reciprocity, 46.
Unfair and Partial, 353.

Unjust and Inequitable, 291.
"Unpatriotic Conspirators,'

247.

We Need a Trade Balance of $500,000,000, 7.
What Counts, 115.

What Else Could They Do? 317.

What Free-Trade in Potatoes Would Do, 104.
What He Does Not Represent, 288.

What He Knows the Least About, 268.
What Kind of Protectionism? 44.
What the Farmer Thinks, 141.

What the Farmer Would Lose, 116.
What the President Said in Chicago, 338.
When the People's Eyes Are Opened, 139.
Where Cummins Is At, 93.

Where Its Interest Lies, 244.
Where Was the Tariff Board, 93.
Which Are the Fools, 305.

Which Way Is Protection Facing? 58.

Why British Manufacturers Favor the Cana-
dían Agreement, 314.

Why Business Halts, 34.

Why Democrats Support the Canadian Agree-
ment, 93.
"We Need It? 364.

Why Do

Why Great Britain Is Solvent, 6.
Why Not Take a Recess? 375.

Why Should He Go to Chicago? 340.
Why They Are Helping Taft, 231.
Why They Oppose a Commission, 32.
Will Attack the Wool Schedule, 176.
William Whitman's Masterly Review, 46.
Wise Words of Warning, 198.
Without a Sinister Motive, 175.
Would Destroy American Woolen Industry,
339.

Would It Benefit New Jersey? 316.
Would Like to See It Killed, 317.

Would Lower Prices to an Export Basis, 231.
Election of President Bound to Feel Sentiment
of Farmers, 216.

Elephant and Mule Team-Washington Corre-
spondence, 182.

Emery, Professor, Defines the Tariff, 218.
Emery's Speech Before Convention Advocating
Tariff Commission, 21.

Emigration Promoted by Taft-Nevada (Ia.)
"Representative," 360.

Emigration to Canada as a Result the Opinion
of Two Protectionists, 268.

England May Be Compelled to Abrogate Other
Treaties, 259.

England's Need of Protection-London Corre-
spondence, 275.

England's Tariff Dilemma-London Correspond-
ence, 259.

English Board of Trade Report Upon Cost of
Living_There and Here, 226.

English Protectionists and Free-Traders Aroused
by Agreement, 101.

Englishmen Comment Upon Oriental Manufac-
turing Development, 36.

Equilibrium Between Agriculture and Manu-
facture Speech, Representative Hinds, 239.
Everitt, John A., States Position of Farmers,

Farm Papers That Are Against Treaty, 156.
Farm Papers Print Protests Against Canadian
Treaty, 171.

Farm Papers That Protest Against Treaty, 150.
Farm Prices of Agricultural Products Decline,
264.

Farm Values Will Not Be Affected by Agree-
ment Thinks President, 337.

to

Farmer and Bogus "Reciprocity"-"The Prairie
Farmer," 256; Asked to Give Up Protection
and No Return, 177; Asks Protection and
Must be Answered-Hiawatha (Kan.)
"World," 162; Buying Less Affects Every
Line-Enid (Okla.) "Events," 87; Buys Less
When Receiving Lower Prices, 128; Com-
pares Protection and Reciprocity Arguments
Cleveland "Leader," 325; From Missouri
Finds Many Flaws in Taft Proposition-
Jacksonville "Farm," 358; Is Himself
Blame-San Francisco Chronicle," 142; Not
Likely to be Conciliated by Reciprocity
Scheme, 59; Not Willing to be Made Goat,
304; Should Have Square Deal-Rochester
Democrat and Chronicle," 132; Should Not
Be Deceived by Outcome-Des Moines (Iowa)
"Capital," 37; Tells What Tariff Reform
Cost Him-Manchester (Ia.) "Press," 85;
Will Leave Democracy-Des Moines "Capi-
tal,' 183; Will Lose Protection Through Ca-
nadian Reciprocity, 58; Would Lose in Many
Crops Under Reciprocity, 116.

"Sun,

Farmers Accused of Having Been Influenced,
by "Boston Herald," 329; Alarmed Not
Groundlessly, 115; Almost a Unit Against It
-Syracuse "Post-Standard," 98; And Farm
Papers Generally Opposed to Agreement, 247;
And Fishermen Not Likely to Endorse Lift-
ing of Protection, 79; And Manufacturers
See Danger-Lewisburgh (Pa.) "News,"234;
And Piecemeal Revision, 47; Appeal to Presi-
dent, 195; Are Not Plutocrats-St. Louis
"Globe-Democrat," 367; Are Not to Be
Fooled-Luverne (Minn.) "Herald," 272; As
Backbone of Republicanism About to Quit,
140; Asked to Answer Questions on Features
of Treaty, 231; Being Heard-Cedar Rapids
"Republican,' 112; Can Not Be Fooled-Des
Moines "Capital,' 368; Deserting Republican
Party Will Be Realized Next Year, 305; Dis-
criminated Against by Reciprocity, 124; Do
Not Deserve to Compete With Cheap Lands
and Labor-"American Stockman," 224; Do
Not Favor Agreement-Manchester (Ia)
"Press," 294; Easily Hold Balance of Power,
219; Favoring Protection Should Awaken, 67;
"Inter-
Fight Reciprocity Action-Chicago
Ocean," 306; Fighting Reciprocity-New York
121; Generally Opposing Canadian
Treaty-Grand Forks "Times," 293; Give Ex-
pression of Needs in "Northwestern Agricul-
turist, 147; Give Reason for Opposing Ca-
nadian Agreement, 113; In Canada Wish Re-
moval of Restrictions on Their Products, 193;
In North Dakota to Hold Mass Meetings
Against Agreement, 199; In Wisconsin Heard
From-Wisconsin "Agriculturist,'
307; Kick
-"National Stockman and Farmer,' 225;
Not Deserting Republican Party, but Reverse,
377; Now Have Inning-Greenville (O.) "Cou-
rier," 42; Of Iowa May State Their Position-
Des Moines "Capital,' Of Northwest Hold
3:
Anti-Free-Trade Meetings, 232; Petition
Shows Remarkable Reaction, 376; Register
Angry Protest Against Canadian Treaty, 171,
178; Should Oppose Free-Trade-Des
Moines "Capital," 85; Should Take Their
Medicine-Des Moines "Capital," 378; Think-
ing for Themselves-"The American Stock-
man,"
Το
206;
San Francisco
Urged
Move Upon Congress-"The New York
Farmer," 202; Who Are Petitioning Not
Ones Who
Will
Fools, 305;
Greater Burden-"The Connecticut

to

to

Extra Session and What It Would Cost, 100.
Extra Session Calls Together Democrats
Pass President's Legislation, 128.
Extra Session May Put Woolen Industry Out
of Business, 198.

Extra Session Not Demanded-Pittsburg "Ga-
zette-Times,"

331.

Extra Session Regrettable-St. Louis "Globe-
Democrat," 137

Extra Session Truly Extraordinary-Luverne
(Minn.) "Herald,'

162.

Extravagance Blamed by James J. Hill for
Conditions of Present Time, 7.

the
Bear
Farmer,"
209; Will Become Alienated-
Washington "Post," 349; Will Benefit by
Agreement Opinion of President, 336; will
"Make Rome Howl"-Binghamton (N. Y.)
"Republican," 271; Will Lose What News-
papers Will Gain by Cheaper Paper, 183; Will
Not Be Compensated for Loss, 334; Will Re-
taliate in 1912-"Wisconsin Agriculturist,"
366; Would Suffer Far More Than They
Would Gain, 291.

Farmers' Free List a Great Move, says Bryan,
303; Bill-Washington Correspondence, 225;
Designed Solely to Benefit Southern Farmers,
393; Fraud-R. E. Thompson in "Irish
World," 287; Interest in Protection, 159; In-
terests Attacked by Dwellers in Cities, 198;
Interests Advocated Diversely, 377; Prosper-
ity Affects All,, 243; View of Reciprocity-
Cleveland "Leader," 121.

Farming Requires Upbuilding-Rochester
"Democrat and Chronicle," 254.
Fielding, Minister, Gives Opinion of Canadian
Agreement, 89.

Finance Committee Against Canadian Agree-

Fishermen Would Suffer Through Special Boun-
ties of Canada, 327.

Fishing Interests of United States Affected by
Agreement, 115.

Flag Must Be Defended by Own Citizens, 262.
Flint and Smoot Debate Piecemeal Revision, 70.
Flour Merchants Furnish Comparison Between
Canada and Home, 129.

Focht, Representative, on Canadian Reciprocity,

170.

Focht, Representative, Defines Genuine Reci-
procity, 334.

Foodstuffs Increasing in Price in Europe, 25.
Fooling With Facts and Figures-Washington
Correspondence, 285; Fordney, Representative,
on Canadian Reciprocity, 169.

Foreign Countries May Ask For Discrimination
Similar to Canadian, 78.

Foreign Prices to be Sought by Members of
Tariff Board, 290.

Foreign Trade Increases Under Protection, 381.
Foreign Trade Showing Is Bad, 46.

Foreign Trade Shows Effect of New Tariff, 32.
Forstman, Julius, Says Revenue Tariff Would
Wipe Out Woolen Industry, 343.

France Protected Farmers by Increased Duties,

241.

France Under Napoleon Prosperous Because of
Protection, 289.
Free-Coinage System

a

in Land-Roswell A.
Benedict, No. 6, Page IV.
Free List Bill Hits Farmers, 273; For News-
papers Joliet (Ill.) "Herald,' 354; Hoax—
Belleville (Ill.) "Advocate,'
322; Not
Square Deal-Washington_"Post,' 248; Offers
No New Advantages to Farmer, 228; Shows
Inconsistencies, 226; Will Irritate and Not
Soothe Bath (N. Y.) "Courier," 286.
Free Meat Menace-Springfield (Mo.) "Repub-
lican," 286.

Free Print Paper the Issue, 365.

Free Raw Materials Advocated by Republicans,
Repudiated by Democrats, 128.

Free-Trade Adopted by Canada and United
States Beneficial to Germany, 140; And What
It Does For Workingmen-London "Evening
News," 2; Apt to Be Installed by Canadian
Pact, 80; Argument Indulged in by Republi-
cans, 94; Bill Passed Again-Washington
Correspondence, 249; Bills Before Congress-
Washington Correspondence, 273; Coming-
New York "World,' 124; Deal Utterly Bad-
San Francisco "Chronicle," 324; Democratic
Bunglers Resort to Venerable Tariff Dodges-
New York "Globe," 306; Effect Upon Both
Sides of the Line, 281; For Farmers' Result
of Revision-Des Moines "Capital," 52;
Greater Loss to Farmer Than Compensation,
334 In Agricultural Products for First Time
in Country, 228; In Agriculture Should Mean
Same in Everything, 176; In Everything
Sought by President With Canada, 137; In
Farm Products a Dangerous Tool-Washing.
ton "Post," No. 8, Page III; In Farm Prod-
ucts and Economic Results, 246; In Farm Prod-
ucts Bad in Rural Districts-Pittsburg "Dis-
patch," 125; In Farm Products Bound
Alienate Farmer-Manchester (Ia.) "Press,"
143; In Farm Products Involves Untold Trou-
ble Elmira (N. Y.) "Advertiser," 318; In
Farm Products Not Relished by Farmers, 152;
In Farm Products Will Endanger Protection,
302;
In Paper Truth-A. G. Paine, Jr., 251;
In Pulp and Paper Would Ruin American
Paper Trade, 81; Legislation Always Menaces
Business, 34; Measure-Marshall (Mo.) "Re-
publican," 307; Not a Benefit to Farmer or
Wage Earner-Cleveland "Leader," 142; Pact
Causes Division in Democracy-Washington
Correspondence, 89; Provided for by Agree-

ment

to

According to Speaker Cannon, 105;
Rather Than Protection Apparent in Canadian
Pact, 80; Reciprocity Platform Means of De-
feat Washington "Post," 223; "Reciprocity"
Scheme of President Defended by Him, 335;
"Reciprocity" Unfair-San Francisco "Chron-
icle," 333; The End of Canadian Agreement
-Des Moines "Capital," 99; Through Elim-
ination-Capitol Hill (Okla.) "News," 83;
To Become an Endless Chain-Clarinda (Ia.)
"Journal," 354

Free-Traders in Britain Not Gratified by Board
of Trade Report, 245.

Free-Traders Not Pleased With Tariff Board
Reports, 301.

Free Traders Ones Who Have Passed the Bill,
332.

Free-Traders Sent to Congress by Farmers-
"National Farmer," 163.

Free Wheat and Protected Flour, 100.
FreeWool-Correspondence in "Springfield Re-
publican," 40.

Free Wool Howled For-Lampassas (Tex.)
"Blade," 333.

Frewen, Moreton, Translates Theory of Pro-
tection. fI.

Frewen. Moreton, Has Good Understanding of
Our System of Protection, 5.

Frye. Senator, Criticises Extra Session Busi-
ness, 317.

GAINES Representative, expresses opinion of
Canadian reciprocity, 170.
Gallinger, Senator, proposes bill for protection
of trade, 34; proposes amendment to strike out
hay, 365.

Gardner. Representative, presents condition of
American fisheries, 115.

German Agreement by Roosevelt deprecated, 29.

Germany Gives Notice of Demanding Same Priv-
ileges Accorded Canada, 137.

Germany Has Cause for Complaint Against Con-
cessions to Canada, 140.

Germany Protected Farmers by Increasing Du-
ties, 241.

Great Britain Not Endorsing Agreement-Eng-
lish "Correspondence," 84.

Glove Workers Receive Lower Wages in Ger-
many Than Here, 300.

Gracy, J. H., Asks Who Will Now Maintain
Protection Policy, 194.

Grain Growers Protest Against Treaty, 214.
Grange of Ohio Addressed by Senator Dick, 124.
Grange Opposition Explained-Norwalk (0.)

"Reflector," 366.

Grangers of Santa Rosa Opposed to Reciprocity
-San Francisco "Chronicle," 252.
Grangers' Attorney Misrepresents League Be-
fore Finance Committee, 340.

Great Britain Collects Higher Tariff than Amer-
ica, No. 1, Page III.

Great Britain Kept from Insolvency by For-
eign Investments, 6.

Great Britain Solvent-San Francisco "Chron-
icle," 7.

Greeley, Horace, Defended Protection in De-
bate, 352, Concluded, No. 25, Page III.
Green, W. R., Judge, Wins Victory in Iowa, 353.
Gunton, George, Seeks Protectionist for 1912,

117.

HALF-MAST the Flag, Union Down-Worces-

cester "Telegram," 75.
Hansbrough, Ex-Senator, Sends Protest of North-
western Grain Growers, 213.

Hard Times of 1895 will be Duplicated, is Pre-
dicted, 139.

Harrison and Blaine on Reciprocity, 264.

Hastings, Arthur C., Predicts Injury to Paper
Trade, 81.

Hats from China Result of Six Cents Per Day
Wage, 19.

Hay Amendment
Adopted, 365.

of Gallinger Should Be

Heisey, A. H., Says Meddling has Created De-
pression, 377.

Heyburn, Senator, Discusses Business and
Politics, 87.

Heyburn, Senator, Makes Sound Protection
Speech, 92; Takes Issue with Ready-made
Clothing Manufacturer, 372.

Hides on Free List Has Resulted Disastrously-
Des Moines Capital," 227.

Hill, "Farmer Jim," Why He Likes It-Crowley
(La.) "Signal," 313.,

Hill, James J., Contradicts Himself, 141.
Hill, James J., Favors Reciprocity for Selfish
Ends, 301.

Hill, James J., for Self Always-Napoleon
(N. D.) "Homestead," 184.

Hinds, Asher P., Delivers Great Speech on
Agreement, 246.

Hinds, Representative, in Powerful Speech, 239.
Home Market Club Protess at Ratification of
Reciprocity, 120.

Home Market Club's View of Negotiations, 170.
Hosiery and Knit Goods Show Benefits of Pro-
tection to Retailer, 140.

House Vote Shows Gain for Sane Politics, 244;
Husbandry Patrons Protest-Washington "Post,"
No. 7, Page IV.

F the Republican Party Is to Live"-Speech
of Ex-Speaker Cannon, 261.
Illinois Farmers Protest-"Farmers' Review,"
318; Protective League Organized, 377.
Immigration Will Be Diverted by Treaty, 141.
Importer Advises in Harmony with Own Inter-
ests-Bristol (Pa.) "Courier," 236.

Imports Falling Off Accounted for by Demo-
crats, 176.

Income Tax Made Way for, 250.

Industrial Depression Will Affect Incomes of
People, 250.

Industrial Independence Not Fostered by Reci-
procity, 119.

Industrial Losses Through Agreement, 230.
Industrial Prosperity Menaced by Tariff Tin-
kering, 153.

277.

Industrial Situation Alarming-Point Pleasant
(W. Va.) "Gazette,'
Industries and How Affected by Reciprocity
Agreement, 62.

Industries in Alabama Seriously Menaced-Bir-
mingham "Age-Herald," 294.

Industries of Every Kind Should Appear Be-
fore Senate Committee, 269.
Industries of Many Kinds Affected by Morse
Bill, 116.

Industries that Are Victim of Reciprocity, 118.
Industries that Are Hurt by Reciprocity Agree-
ment, 124.

Industries Threatened by Free List, 229.
Industry of Farmers to go for Naught-"Na-
tional Stockman & Farmer," 203.

Insurgent Ideas that Have Reacted Upon the
Creators, 155.

Insurgent Insincerity-Yokima (Wash.) "Re-
public," 250.

Insurgent Senators Show First Indication of
Sense in Position, 317.

Insurgency Responsible for Extra Session-
Hiawatha (Kan.) "World," 233.
Insurgents and Democratic Free-Traders Radi-
cally Differ, 135.

Insurgents and Democrats in Dangerous Coali-
tion, 364.

Insurgents Confounded with Protectionists, 44.
Insurgents Kept Conspicuous by Tariff Attacks,
174.

Insurgents May Eat Their Words-Des Moines
"Capital," 97..

Insurgents Now Condemned by New York
"Times," 100.

Insurgents Willing to Hurt Farmers, 191.
Investments will be Transferred to Canada-
Des Moines "Capital," 237.

Iowa Election a Straw that Shows, 353.
Iowa Election Illustrates Confusion Created by
President in Party, 326.

Iowa Farmers Against Reciprocity Treaty-Des
Moines "Capital," 360.
Iowa Newspapers Poll Regarding Paper
Product, 376.

in

Ireland Illustrates Result of Free Trade, 20.
Iron & Steel Association's Report on Tariff Re-
vision, 313.

It Is Not American Protection-Washington Cor-
respondence. 94.

JAM Makers Now Paupers in England-San

Francisco "Chronicle," 70.

Japanese Tariff as Affecting England, 38.
Jones, Aaron, of National Grange on Canadian
Agreement, 95.

Jones, Aaron, Representing National Grange,
Presents Farmer's View, 115.

Juilliard, A. D., Letter of to Wool Growers, 1.
Juilliard, A. D. Sounds Note of Alarm, 266.
Justice, Theodore, Addresses Letter to Wool
Growers' Convention, 2.

Justice, Theodore, Answers Magnus Brown, 10.
Kasson Treaties Differently Handled from Ca-
nadian, 363.

Kenyon, Senator, Fit Mate for Cummins, 229.

LABOR and Wages Losers through Canadian
Treaty, 230.

Labor that Is Free to Compete with Slave
Labor, 262.

Laboring Man Affected by Loss to Farmer-
Wellsboro (Pa.) "Agitator," 208.

La Follette Quoted by Moreton Frewen, 25.
LaFollette, Senator, Attacks Faith of Majority,

174.

Land Marked Up in Canada-Cedar Rapids
"Republican," 159.

Lands of South Have Been Restored through
Diversified Industries, 262.

Larimore, W. G., Shows How Farmers will
Lose, 334.

Laurier, Sir Wilfred, Compliments Fielding and
Patterson, 265.

Lemon Duty-San Francisco "Chronicle," 38.
Lenroot, Representative, Criticises Opinion of
Tariff League, 32.

Lippitt, Senator, Election of, Cause of Congratu
lation, 46.

Liverpool Does Not Fix Price of Wheat, 271.
Lloyd, D. Frank, Presents Commendable Re-
port of Customs Litigation, 61.

Lodge, Senator, Not Consistent as a Protec-
tionist, 6.

Louisiana Farmers Are Opposed for Selfish Rea-
sons--Crowley (La.) "Signal," 277.

Lower Prices for Farmers through Low Tar-
iff-Des Moines "Capital," 53.

Luke, John G., Predicts Injury to

Trade, 81.

Paper

Lumber and Wood Pulp Supply Growing Ex-
hausted, Says President, 335.

Lumber Features of Canada Free List, 227.
Lyman, Chester W., Predicts Injury to Paper
Trade, 81.

MacVeagh, Secretary, and Cheese-Parink Econ-
omy, 305.

MacVeagh, Secretary, Places Creosote Upon
Free List, 326.

Maine Illustrates what Fair Markets will Do, 243.
Majority Report of House Makes Monstrous As-
sertions, 129.

Malby, Representative, On Canadian Reciproc-
ity, 170.

Malby, Representative, Says Presidential Elec-
tion will Suffer, 216.

Mann, Representative, Introduces "Pop Gun"
Tariff Bills, 19.

Manufactures from Europe Could Come in by
Way of Canada, 110.

Manufactures in New Jersey will Not Be Voted
Protection by Farmers, 316.

Manufacturers' Club Addressed by Charles He-
ber Clark, 118.

Manufacturers Not Justified in Opening Books
for Investigation, 34.

Manufacturers Protest Against Free Entry of
Cream Separators, 110.

Manufacturing by Orientals Replacing Import-
ed Goods, 33..

Market Values Drooping One Result-Washing-
ton "Post," 145.

Marks, M. M., Not Consistent, 372.

McCall, Representative, Again Presents Cana-
dian Treaty, 218.

McCall, Representative, Responsible for Majority
Report, 129.

McCall, Samuel W., Answered by Nabum J.
Bachelder, 247.

McCleary, James T., Says People Rule Coun-
try, 47.

McCleary, James T., Speaks on Protection for
All, 202.

McClure, S. W., Reviews Underwood Bill, 347.
McCumber, Senator, Sounds Note of Warn-
ing, 198.

McKinley Idea of Reciprocity-Millersville (Pa.)
"Herald," 361.

McKinley and Taft Not Comparable in Treaty
Making, 363.

McRae, Milton, Supports_Treaty Because Ig-
norant of It, 364; Was Talking for Himself—
Des Moines Capital," 379.

Meat Supply Invariably Reduced with Lower
Wool Tariffs, 154.

Members of the Senate Finance Committee, 290.
Merchant Marine Advocated by Meeting in
Washington, 35.

Merchant Marine to be Revived in Bill by Rep-
resentative Sulzer, 330.

Merchants' Association Endorses Canadian
Agreement, 105.

Message of President Upon Canadian Agree-
ment, 215.

Meyercord, George R., Predicts Emigration of
Our Farmers to Canada, 246.
Michigan Farmers Refuse to Endorse Treaty,

223.

Minnesota Farmers Petition Not Work of Grang.
ers Attorneys, 365.

Minnesota Joins the Movement-St. Paul "Pio-
neer Press, 252.

Minority Report of House on Reciprocity, 130.
Missouri Farmers Oppose It-Albany (Mo.)
"Capital," 379.

Molesworth Contrasts Conditions in Great Brit-
ain and America "The Empire Illustrated,"
16.

Mondell, Representative, Analyzes Tariff Pro-
tection, 50.

Morse, Representative, Introduces Bill for Free
Building Materials, 116.

Mutton Supply Under Various Rates of Duty, 9.

"Post-Telegram," 357.

Newspaper Correspondent Writes True Condi-
tion in Washington, 317.

Newspaper Favors Treaty Selfishly-Midland
(Mich.) "Republican," 223.

Newspaper Gleanings on Protection, No. 1, Page
III, 23, 27; No. 9, Page IV, 51, 71, 73, 92,
122, 133, 147, 189, 210; No. 15, Page IV;
No. 16, Page IV; No. 17, Page IV, 278.
Newspaper Sordidness to Blame-Pittsburg
"Gazette-Times," 380.

Newspapers Have Been Unfair and Partial, 353.
Newspapers in New York All for Canadian
Reciprocity, 176.

Newspapers Opposed to Reciprocity Farmer's
Best Friend-Grand Forks (N. D.) "Times,"
236.

Newspapers that Cannot Get Farmer's View-
point, 141.

Newspapers Will Only Derive Temporary Gain,
315.

New York Farmer's Ultimatum-Rochester
"Democrat and Chronicle," 257.

New York Not Interested in Needs of Rest of
Country, 176.

New York Times" Now Turns Upon Insur-
gents, 199.

Nixon, Lewis, on Importance of American Ship-
ping, 39.

Non-Competitive Industries that Do Not Need
Protection, 343.

North Dakota Farmers Protest Against Treaty in
Vain, 219.

Northern Railroad Wants Canadian Treaty, 264.
Northwest to Send Avalanche of Protest-Wash-
ington "Post," 85.

"Northwestern Agriculturist" Circulates Petition
Against Treaty, 147..
Northwestern Opposition Grows Apace-Deer
River (Minn.)" "News,' 200.

HARE, Father, Protests Against Free Cot-
ton in Canadian Agreement, 269.
Ohio Apt to Be Taken Out of Republican Elec-
toral Column, 246.

Ohio Farmers Oppose Treaty-"National Stock-
man and Farmer," 206.

Opinions of Canadian Farmers Given by Rep-
resentative Campbell, 193.

Paine, A. G., Jr., Tells About Free-Trade in
Paper, 251.

Panic Apt to Result from Present Agitation, 5.
Paper and Free-Trade, 251.

Paper and Pulp Amendment a Reasonable One,
327.

Paper Industry Threatened with Destruction, 81.
Paper Makers of Michigan Will Be Ruined, 281.
Paper Provision Cause of Endorsement by Press
-Fredonia (Kan.) "Citizen," 294.

Payne, Augustus G., Predicts Injury to Paper
Industry, 81.

Penrose, Senator, Informed of Erroneous Testi-
mony About League, 340; Extolled for For-
getting His Protectionism, 376.

Personnel of Tariff Board Experts as Organ-
ized So Far, 8.

Peters, Representative, Not Posted Upon Wool
Industry, 352.

Petition Against Canadian Treaty-"Northwest-
ern Agriculturist," 148.

Pearl Button Industry Developed Under Protec-
tion, No. 1, Page III.

Philadelphia Textile School Reunion Dinner,

372.

Piecemeal Revision Favored by Free-Traders, 59.
Piecemeal Revision Now Begins, 280..
Piecemeal Revision Popular, Says President. 335.
Plate Glass Industry in Canada Would Receive
Greater Benefit, 325:

Political Aspect of New Congress Unique in
History, 129:

Political Considerations a Necessity in Consid-
ering Reciprocity, 305.

Politics and Business Conditions-"Fiber and
Fabric," 321.

Politics Meddling with Business-"Bulletin Iron
and Steel Association."

Politics of Agreement Belong to Ragtime and
Crazy Quilt, 231.

Postal Cards Urged as Means of Defeating Ca-
nadian Agreement, 198.

Potash Discrimination by Germany Should Be
Retaliated, 34.

Potatoes Illustrated Operation of Law of Price
Control, 242.

Potatoes Would Be Affected by Reciprocity, 1
Poultry Could be Sent in from Canada in Great
Quantities, 91.

Powers, Representative, Declares Bill Is a Free-
Trade Measure, 311.

Preferential of Canada Not a Feature in Reci-
procity Negotiations, 229.

President Addressed by Grain Growers of North-
west, 213.

President and Congress Feel Effect of Oppo-
sition to Tariff Commission, 5.

President and the Farmers-San Francisco
"Chronicle," 319.

President Claiming to Be Republican Turns Back
on His Own Party, 126.
President Consults Democrats

"Correspondence," 123.

-

Washington

President to Depend Upon Democrats to Pass
Reciprocity, 60.

President Upheld by Democrats in House in His
Free-Trade Position, 225.

President Lobbying to Secure Passage of Treaty,

274.

----

President's Complications, The Washington
"Correspondence," 135.

President's Power Questioned in Legislation, 152.
President's Remarkable Attitude in Matter of
Negotiating Treaty, 140.

Price High for Uncertainty of Benefits from
Reciprocity-Des Moines "Capital," 77.
Price to Consumer Cannot Mean Same Price to
Farmer-Chicago "Dairy Products," 224.
Prices at Home to Be Leveled Down by Cana-
dian Reciprocity, 359.

Prices Controlled by Ancient Law, 242.
Prices Falling with Reduced Business-Benton
(Ill.) "Republican," 331.

Prices for Farm Products Falsely Stated-
Midland (Mich.) "Republican," 380.
Prices for Meats Question for Farmer-Enid
(Okla.) "Events," 16.

Prices for Wheat Affected by Approval of Reci-
procity, 104.

Prices for Wool Explained by William Whit-

man, 15.

Prices Higher Thought to Be Ooutcome of Reci-
procity by British, 320.

Prices Immediately Affected by Passage of Treaty
in House, 138.

Prices in Europe on Increase, 35.
Prices Little Affected by Tariff, 26.
Prices Lowered by Agitation-Independence
(Kan.) "Tribune,' 287.

Prices Lowered Would Mean Economic Loss,
128.

Prices Not to Be Reduced, Why Have Reci-
procity?-Pittsburg "Gagette-Times," 348.
Prices of Crops in Canada and Here Compared,

129.

Prices of Meats in English Possessions, 24.
Prices Slightly Affected by Tariff-Chicago "In-
ter-Ocean,'

9.

Print Paper Cost the Cause of Newspaper De-
fections, 155.

Proceedings of Annual Meeting of Tariff League,
55.

Produce Merchant Analyzes Canadian Reci-
procity Features, 91.

Producers Making Impression on Finance Com-
mittee, 323.

Products from Canada Already Compete with
Domestic-Norwich (Conn.) "Bulletin," 87.
Products of Farmer Need Protection as Well
as of Manufacturers-Cedar Rapids "Republi-
can," 86.
Products of Farm will Bring Lower Price, 205.
Progressive Republicans May Not Contribute to
Passage of Reciprocity, 126.

Prospective Tariff Tinkering-Washington "Cor-
respondence," 220.

Protected Interests Attacked by "Journal of
Commerce,' 155.

Protected Interests in Alabama Repudiated by
Their Representative, 288.
Protection Abandonment in Proposed Treaty
with Canada, 67; About to be Smashed by
Democrats, 45: And Silk-Walter J. Ballard,
47; Apt to be Defeated in 1912, 5; As Under-
stood by Moreton Frewen, 5; As Viewed by
President-San Francisco "Chronicle," 307;
Assailed by Republican President as Did Dem-
ocratic, 351; Being Assassinated by Republi-
cans, 378; Better to Have Been Abandoned
Years Ago than Now, 80; Defended by Hor-
ace Greeley, 358; Doctrine Reaffirmed in
Iowa, 328; Downfall Being Worked for,
271; First Attacked by City Rather than
Rural Interests, 198; For All or for None
James T. McCleary, 202; Fishermen of
Gloucester a Just Claim, 60; For Wool-
Letter of A. D. Juilliard, 1: For Wool-Will.
iam Whitman, 15; For Wool and Woolens-
Julius Forstman, 343; Has Cheapened Two
Articles of Wearing Apparel, 140; Helps the
Farmers Washington Correspondence, 160;
Lost to Farmer, but Retained for Manufactur-
er, 58; Needed by Both Interests-The New
York Farmer,' 201; No Longer Needed, a
Growing Belief, 293; Not Heeded by Demo-
crats, 220; Not Upheld in Canadian Treaty,
79; Of Fathers Being Forgot J. W. Alfree,
107; Of Proper Sort Only Made by Repub-
licans Yorkville (Ill.) "Record," 348; Of
Tariff Analyzed by Representative Mondell,
50; Party Have No New Reason for Stultify-
ing Itself, 338; Permanency Menaced, 302;
Should be Upheld by President Taft, 109;
Taken Out of Tariff by Aid of Insurgents, 42;
The One Policy to Keep Republican Party
Alive, 261; The Only Hope-Plaza_(N. D.)
"Pioneer," 144; To be Attacked by Proposing
Amendments to Treaty, 135; To Manufactures
Will Not be Supported by Farmers, 300; Un-
dervalued by President, 374; When Ade-
quate Shown to Have Increased Supply
of Flesh, 9.

Protectionism Has Received Worst Blow of
Years in Canadian Agreement, 113; Of Napo-
leon Bonaparte, 289; Of Sir Guilford Moles-
worth Accounted for, 16; Upheld Only Rem-
edy for Present Stagnation, 266.
"Protectionist" and Free-Trader in Accord on
Same Platform, 100.

Protectionist Dies in Henry M. Steel, 76.
Protectionists and Insurgents Defined, 44.
Protectionists Attacked by New York Times,"

154.

Protectionists Warned of Doom Through Neg-
lect, 350.

Protective Principle Violated by Reciprocity, 120.
Protective Tariff Breakdown Object of Demo-
cratic Effort, 231.

Protective Tariff Tested-Colfax (Ia.) "Clip-
per," 50.

Protest from Everywhere San Francisco
"Chronicle," 237..

Protests by Angry Farmers, 171.

Protests Should Be Made by Farmers-Plaza
(N. D.) "Pioneer," 185.

Pulp and Paper Free Not Sufficient Excuse, 80.
Pulp and Paper Mill Materials to Be Admitted
Free, 116.
Purchasing Power Affected by Tariff Agitation,

ule K-"American Stockman," 235; And the
Farmer-Tacoma "Ledger," 89; And the Free
List Deplored by Joseph E. Wood, 318; As
Understood by McKinley, 103; As Viewed by
Charles Heber Clark, 117; Bargain with Can-
ada Given in Full, 62; Both Sectional and
Partisan-Mulhall (Okla.) "Enterprise," 368;
Deal Places Us in False Position with Coun
332; Deal Gives Satisfaction to Governor Foss,
59; Denounced in Democratic Campaign Text
Book, 311; Dicker Good for Canada-Albany
"Journal," 85; Embarrassments-San Francis-
co "Chronicle," 145; Endorsed by President
and Democratic Speaker, 90; Experiences
with Various Countries, 118; Features as Un-
derstood by Canadian Negotiators, 63; Friends
Mostly Democrats-St. Louis "Globe-Demo-
crat,"
Is a Step Backward-New York
357;
"Journal of Commerce," 300; Is Losing
Ground-Washington "Correspondence," 323;
Is More in Doubt-Washington "Correspond-
ence," 325: Legislation has Placed Republican
Party in Worst Dilemma, 114: Not a McKin
ley Type-Albany "Journal," 77; Not Favored
by Country Generally, 316; Not of the Repub-
lican Sort, 305; Not to Replace Protection in
McKinley's Idea, 103; Not Wanted by Promi-
nent Canadian-New York "Sun," 72; Oppo-
nents Have Not Been Noted ir Newspapers,
353; Paved Way for Free List, 303; Rainbow
Still Being Chased, 20; Schemes Really Un-
equal Compacts, 58; Should be Fair, Says
Western Farmer, 214; Sponsors Must Take
Consequences-Grand Fork "Times," 354;
Suddenly Favored by Democracy-Washing
ton "Correspondence," 158; Supporters Should
Read British Board of Trade Report, 245;
That Establishes Soup-Houses, 266; That i
Unfair-Charles Heber Clark, 118; Treaties
Negotiated by Roosevelt to Blame for Depres-
sion, 266; Truly Illustrated Bewteen States-
E. C. Williams, 259; When Genuine, Explained
by Representative Focht, 334; Will Make Iowa
Suffer-Des Moines "Capital," 143; Will Not
Compromise with Insurgents San Francisco
"Chronicle," 380; With Canada-Correspond-
ence, Robert E. Thompson, 30; With Canada
and the Tariff League's Position, 177; Wit-
nesses Show Self Interest, 325.
Reciprocity Pact Game of Giveaway-Sioux City
"Journal," 361.

Reciprocity's Thorny
"Chronicle," 225.

Path-San Francisco

Reed, Thomas B., Quoted by Moreton Frewen,

12.

Reform of Monetary System Overshadowing
Question, 375.

Report of Customs Litigation for Year, 61.
Reports Read at Annual Meeting of Tariff
League, 55..

be
295;

Republican Administration Gone Democratic, 90;
Defined by Vice-President Sherman, 129; De-
sertion Leaves Protection Abandoned, 194;
Leaders Dismayed and Discouraged, 66; Party
Always Heretofore Recognized Needs of Farm-
er, 141; Party Drifting Into Dangerous Chan-
nels, 90; Party Held Together by Farmer's
Vote, 114; Party Not Deserving Support of
Farmer-Rochester "Democrat and Chronicle,"
258; Party Owes Existence to Protection, 261;
Party Policy Forgotten, 274; Party to
Abondoned-Cayuga County" "News,"
Party Will Hear from Farmers Next Year,
290; Platform Recalled to President Taft, 213;
Policy Reversed-Chanute (Kan.) "Times,'
192; President and Democratic Free-Trader in
Accord-Washington "Correspondence," 100;
President Calling Democratic Congress May
Not End as He Wishes, 174; President De-
pends Upon Democrats to Put Through Treaty,
138; President First to Begin Free-Trade
Scheme, 290; President Joins with Democratic
in Cries of Perfidy, 351; President Strange
Leader for Free-Traders, 246; President's
Strange Procedure, 312; Principles Betrayed-
Cayuga County "News," 292; Representatives
Who Voted for "Farmers' Free List," 303;
Senator from North Dakota Opposed to Agree.
ment, 111; Senator's Actions Cease to be
Amazing, 377-

Republicans Find Measure Malodorous, 377;
In Hole Through Adoption of Treaty, 158;
In Kansas Not for Taft, 352; Split Over Reci-
procity, 100; Still Responsible if Not in
Control, 376; Tell Truths About Diverting
Men and Capital, 311; To Lose in Presiden-
tial Election-Des Moines "Capital," 144;
Who Dissented, 139.
Republican's Protest-Cedar Rapids "Republi-
No. 10, Page IV.
Republicanism Hangs Upon Protection Only. 45.
Resolution Adopted by Tariff League at Annual
Meeting, 55.

can,'

Resolution Passed by Newspaper Publishers' As-
sociation, 267.

Resolutions of League Prove Prophecy of Tar-
iff Commission Results, 18.

Resolutions Passed by National Wool Growers,

Revenue to Be Procured at Cost of Production,
346.

Revenues to Be Lost with Revision of Tariff, 221.
Revision by Piecemeal Deprecated by Tariff
League, 53..

Revision by Piecemeal Discussed by Senator Hey-
burn, 87.

Revision Downward to Increase Cost of Liv-
ing, 329.

Revision of Tariff Contemplated by Underwood,

45.

Revision of Tariff Likely Outcome of Extra Ses-
sion-Manchester (Ia.) "Press," 202.
Revision of Schedule K as Proposed, 341.
Revision of Textile Schedules that May Be
Added to Canadian Treaty, 136.
Revision of the Tariff Intended to End Pro-
tection, 81.

Revisionists Beginning to Hedge-Cedar Rapids
"Republican," 145.

Reyburn, Another, in Field-Philadelphia "In-
quirer," 301.

Rice Duty to be Maintained by Texans, 39.
Ridder, Herman, Presents Free-Trade Side of
Paper Trade View, 81.

Ridder, Herman, Urges Publishers to Urge Ca-
nadian Treaty Passage, 270.
Roberts, George E., Not Concerned with Future
of American Industries, 81.

Roosevelt Tariff Ripping Cause of Present De-
pression, 266.

Roosevelt's Mistake in German Agreement, 29.
Root Amendment Apt to Endanger Passage of
Bill, 337

Root, Senator, Variously Described by Free-
Trade Papers, 327

Root's, Senator, Amendment Likely to be Adopt-
ed-Washington "Correspondence," 311; Deser-
tion, 378; Statement Not so Amazing, 376.
Rural Welfare and Legislative Agent's League
Protest Against Agreement, 113.

SCHEDULE Analysis Shows Dangers in Piece-

meal Revision, 68.

Schedule K Not Prohibitive, 345; To be Revised
by Democrat, 280; To be Smashed-Pittsburg
"Gazette-Times," 236.

Schedule Revision Fatal to Protection, 59.
Selfishness and Humbug-Brooklyn "Times," 96.
Selfishness of Newspaper Publishers Under the
Present Condition, 267.

Senate Apt to Pass Bill Through Votes of Dem-
ocrats, 366.

Senate Finance Committee Does Right Thing in
Reporting Reciprocity, 117.

Senate Coalition a Dangerous One, 364.
Senate Committee Majority Report on Reciproc-
ity, 359.

Senate Finance Committee will Grant Hearings,

Need of Tariff, 113.

Endorses

Farmers'

Sherman, Vice-President, Not an Undesirable
Candidate, 352.

Shipping Most Important to Americans, 39.
Shoddy Deluge Would Follow Revision of Wool
Schedule, 18.

Silk Association Addressed by Senator Heyburn,
87.

Silk Industry and Protection, 47.

Sinister Motives Attributed to Tariff League-
Michigan "Dairy Farmer." 185.
Situation in Washington-Washington "Corre-
spondence," 66.

Slow Work of Tariff Board-Washington "Cor-
respondence." 8.

Smoot and Flint Have Interesting Debate, 70.
Smoot, Senator, Sees End of Protection in
Piecemeal Revision, 59.

Sound on Piecemeal Revision-Washington Cor-
respondence, 70.

South American Countries May Get Reciprocity
Too, 100.

South American Trade to be Protected Through
Proposed Legislation, 34.
Southern Farmers Would Benefit at Expense
of Northern-Grand Forks "Times," 275.
Canadian
Speeches Strong in Opposition to
Agreement, 273.

Free-

Stahl, John M., Representing Farmers' League,
Opposed to Agreement, 113.
Standpatters Advised to Not Obstruct
Trade-San Francisco "Chronicle," 159.
Standpatters Being Joined by Renegade Farm-
ers Enid (Okla.) “Events," 254.
"Statesman" of Oregon Gone Democratic, 247.
Steamship Combine-"Marine Journal,"
Steel, Henry M., Death of, 76.
Steel, Henry M., Death of, 80.
Steel, Henry M., Photo of, 80.
Steel Mills Shut Down Pending Entry of Free
Products, 247.

31.

Steel Trust Favors Agreement, 265.
Stimson, Secretary. Another Free-Trader. 326.
Stock Raisers Will Be Ruined-Washington
"Post," 295.

Stockmen Demand Duty Upon Stock and Farm
Products-Kansas City Journal," 324.

Stone, Melville, Gives Impressions of Oriental
Labor, 30.

Stone, Senator, Warns Farmers Not to Threaten,
304.

Strassburger, W. J., Shows Unfairness of Plate
Glass Concessions, 325.

Sulzer, Representative, Proposes to Revive Mer-
chant Marine, 330.

TABLE Showing Fluctuations of Meat Supply

Under Present Wool Duties, 9.
Taft, President, Active in Urging Tariff Board.
22; Accused of Hastening End of Protection-
Albany "Journal," No. 9, Page IV.; Acknowl-
edges that He Was Not Tricked, 219; And
Clark Reciprocity-Macon (Mo.) "Times-Dem-
ocrat," 321; And Currency Reform, 375;
And Democrats'
Has
Hitchup
Awkward
Complications, 182; And Knox May Only
Some Steubenville (0.) "Herald,"
275; And Other Free-Traders Misled-Grand
Forks (N. D.) "Times," 232; And the Farm-
ers-Washington Correspondence, 299; And

Farmers Chicago "Drovers' Journal,"
381; Apparently Blind to Democratic Schemes,
289; Applauded by Democratic Paper, 80; As
ment on Treaty, 175; Ignored the Tariff Board
Eastern Interests"The Farm," Jacksonville,
Ill., No. 97; Censured by "Times,'
117; Dem-
ocratic Measure Places President in Absurd
Position, 329; Deprecates "Artificial Wall."
141; Disciple of "One-Man Politics,"_138;
Does Not Understand Protection-San Fran-
cisco "Chronicle," 184; Erred in His Secrecy
Regarding Negotiations, 350; Erred in Judg.
ment on Treaty, 176; Ignored the Tariff Board
-Washington "Correspondence," 301; In Ar-
rangement with Democrats in Tariff Wrecking,
230; In Calling Extra Session Makes Extraor-
dinary Record, 128; Is Lobbying with Sen-
ators Washington "Correspondence,"
Knows Little About Tariff-Cedar Rapids
"Republican," 163; Leadership Bad Because
Un-Republican-Keosauqua (Ia.) "Republi-
319; Making Mischief by Utterances,
374: Must Have Imperfect Conception
of Economic Principles, 304; Neither Politi-
cian Nor Statesman-Dayton (O.) "Reporter,"
163; Not the Republican Party-Elkton (Md.)
"Whig," No. 23, Page IV; Not Needed to De-
fend Agreement if so Popular, 340; Not Un-
derstanding McKinley Idea of Reciprocity,
104; Places Himself in Queer Company, 114;
Policy of Downward Revision Has Wrought
Damage, 312; Program Results in Converting
Republican Districts Into Democratic, 326;
Quoted Constantly by Enemies of Protection,
352; Seems to Be Log-rolling, 352; Seems
Troubled by Possibility of Amendments. 323;
Set Example for Democrats, Not Seek Infor-
mation. 221; Sought Free-Trade in Everything
with Canada, 137; Speaking in West Hurt
Agreement, 89; Still Harping on "Artificial
Barriers," 267; Talks About What He Knows
Least, 268; Thinks Country Is in Favor of
Agreement, 215; Will Be in Doubtful Position
-Clarinda (Ia.) "Journal," 2; Will Probably
Be Asked to Bargain with Democrats, 158;
Working with Democrats and Insurgents, 371;
"Taft Senators" in Sad Predicament, 365.
Taft's, President, Chicago Speech, 338; Conces-
sion to Democrats-Denver "Republican," 296;
Error in Endorsing Canadian Agreement, 94;
President, "High Plane," 109.

Tarbell, Misrepresents About Tin Plate, 17.
Tariff Agitation Conceded to Be Disastrous, 33:
Always Subject for Democrats-"Greenville
(0.) "Courier," 39: And Cost of Living-Cap-
ital Hill (Okla.) "News." 17: And Cost of
Meat-Correspondence, Ezra C. Williams, 24:

And

in

Foreign Trade-E. P. Miller, 381
And Honest Clothing-Kansas City "Journal."
41; And Textile Trade, Presentment by Will-
iam Whitman, 48; And the Toilers-New York
"Tribune," 296; And the Food Question-
New York "Daily Trade Record," 9; Bene-
fits to Industries-Capitol Hill (Okla.)
"News," 72; Board Bill as Passed by Senate.
142; Board Employs Subsidized Writer. 47
Board Favored by Progressives, 126; Board
Ignored by President Taft, 301: Board Investi-
gators, Hints to, 291; Board Not Called Upon
Canadian Negotiations, 93 Board Not
Making Great Progress, 8; Board Opposed
by National Grange, 197; Board Report Ig-
nored by President, 274; Changes Threaten
Business Stability, 34; Commission a Useless
and Expensive Body, 32; Advocates Helped b
Attitude of President Taft, 21; Advocates
Generally Opposed to Protection, 32: Costly
and Inexpedient, 18; Doubtful-Washington
"Correspondence," 36: Has No Real Reason
for Being Albany "Journal." 95: Legisla
tion-Washington "Correspondence," 22: No
Reason for Existing, 55: Not Currency, Cause
of Depression. 375: Not Heeded by Pres-
ident After All, 219; Not Organized in Behalf
of Protection, 92; Objections Fairly Stated
by Trade Paper, 29; Of Germany and Home
Compared. 347; Powers-Aacoma "Ledger,"
9: Productive of Queer Assumptions, 80;
Sounds Well-Washington Post," 87; Suc-
cess Threatened by Senators-Washington
"Post," 31: Construction Difficulties Now
Known by Democrats-Binghamton "Republi-

177

can, 184; Facts Not Easy of AscertainmentPhiladelphia "Ledger," 84; For All or Tariff for None-"Farm Journal," Philadelphia, 321; Gleanings from Newspapers, 98; Handled by the Democrats in a Way Past Understanding, 139; Has Helped Treasury-Cedar Rapids "Republican,' 52; If Now Should Permit Time Between Enactment and Operation, 347: In Britain-London Correspondence, 38; In the Developing of Wool Industry, 46; Leagues Accused of Sinister Motives, 175; League and Alleged "Reciprocity" with Canada, League Criticised by "Journal of Commerce,' 155; League Opposed to Bogus Reciprocity, 169; League Quoted by Representative Underwood, 288; League's Annual Meeting, 53: Legislation Fear Holding Up Business, 317; Legislation "Predigested" Not a Safe Method, 338; Opinions of Press, 35; On Rice-Ezra C. Williams, 39; Protection Analyzed by Representative Mondell, 50; Protection Not Intended to Apply on Raw Materials, 36; Quarrels with World May Develop-Pittsburg "Gazette-Times," No. 6, Page III; Question Divides Democrats, 41; Reduction Apt to Mean Wage Reduction at This Time, 6; Reduction Basis Necessary to Use in Revision, 345; Reduction Will Insure First Class Panic, 27; Reform Will Cost Farmer More Than Protection-Galveston "News," 357; Reformer at His Customary Stunt-Troy "Times," 334: Reduction on Wool Means Loss in Revenue, 362; Revision and Dangerous Effects-Albany "Journal," 43; Revision Plan Will Work Harm-Washington "Post," 144; Ripping all Summer Merely to Bring About Canadian Reciprocity-Des Moines "Capital," 161; Simply a Matter of Emotion, Says Professor Emery, 218; Smash to Be Aim of Democrats -Washington "Correspondence," 137; Tinkering Fatal to All Industries, Says "Wall Street Journal," 153; To Be Sweepingly Reduced by Democrats, 220; Trade Swaps Prove Uneven Swaps, 118.

Taxation by Free List Items Averages LittleBinghamton "Republican," 323.

Telegrams by the Hundred Thousands-"The American Stockman," 188.

Texas Cattlemen Want Protection-San Antonio "Express," 319.

Text of Farmers' Free List, 227.
Text of Longworth Bill, 23.

Text of Proposed Revision of Schedule K, 341.
Textile Industry Is the Goa-"Fibre and Fabric,"

43.

Textile Trade and Tariff as Presented by William Whitman, 48.

Theory of American Protection-Moreton Frewen, 25.

Thompson, Robert Ellis, Analyzes Canadian Agreement, 106.

Thompson, Wm. H., Speaks for "Lincoln Protective League," 377.

Ticket for 1912 that Might Catch All-Cam. bridge (Md.) "Journal," 125.

"Times," New York, Censures President for Etra Session, 117.

Tin Plate Misrepresentation-San "Chronicle," 17.

Tin Plate World-wide Prices, 25.

Francisco

Trade Agreement Should be Submitted to People, 153.

Trade Agreements May Not Be Made by President, 261.

Trade Balance Needed to Offset Foreign Drain of Gold, 7.

Trade Newspaper Fairly States Objections to Tariff Commission, 29.

Treaties of Past Caused Injuries to American Trade, 78.

Treaty Advocated by Newspapers for Selfish Reasons, 155.

Treaty Conditions offered by President Show

Astounding Attitude, 140.

Treaty, If Passed, Predicted to Cause Downfall of Premier of Canada, 153.

WAGES and Spending Money Here and in England Compared, 12.

Wages Averaged for Various Sections, 42. Wages Higher in United States in Woolen Business, 344

Wages in Ireland Low Because of Withdrawal of Protection, 20.

Wages in South Lower Than in North, 42. Wages of Producer Distributed at Home Instead of Abroad, 329.

Wages Paid to Japanese as Compared With American, 154.

Wages Reduced Apt to Follow Tariff Reduction at This Time, 6.

Warren, Senator, Speaks Upon Injury to Wool Industry, 82.

Ways and Means Committee See No Necessity of Heeding Reason for Call, 198. Western Canada as a Competitor, 242. Wheat as an Illustration of Republican Ridiculous Position, oo.

Wheat Growing Competition-J. W. Alfree, 257. Wheat Grown in Canada Yields Double Crop, 141.

Wheat in Minneapolis and in Canada-Grand Forks (N. D.) "Times," 225.

Wheat Lands Development in Northwest, 263. Wheat Largely Cultivated by British Possessions,

ΤΟΙ,

Wheat Prices Compared Between Canada and
Here, 193.

Wheat Prices Here and in Canada, 129.
Wheat Prices Here and in CSanada, 205.
Wheat Prices Rose and Declined With Passage
of Treaty in House, 138.

Wheat Prices Would Be Lowered to Export
Basis, 231.

White, W. N., Analyzes Produce Features of Candian Pact, 91.

Whitman, William, Complimented by Dinner, 268.

Whitman, William, Exposes Misrepresentations About Prices, 15.

Whitman, William, to be Acclaimed by Banquet,

231.

Who Will Maintain Protection?-"The Prairie Farmer," 104.

Wilkinson, Col., Testifies for Farmers, 377. Williams, Ezra C., Cites Illustration of True Reciprocity, 259.

94.

Wilsons and Gormans Now Enter-Washington
Correspondence, 41.

Wilson's Secretary, Change of Front, 105.
Wire Nails and Steel Rails Prices, 25.
Wise, John S., Gives Review of Situation, 177.
Wise, Jr., John S., On Direct Election of Sena-
tors, 309.

Wood, Charles H., Speaks Upon Injury to Wool
Manufacturers, 82.

Wood, John P., Speaks Upon Injury Toward Industry, 82.

Wood, Joseph E., Addresses Senate Against Reciprocity and Free List, 318.

Wood, Joseph E., Says Reciprocity is a Step Backwards, 300.

Wood, Joseph E., Talks of Tariff and Toilers, 296.

Wood, President, Denies Discrimination, 39.
Wood Pulp Cost in Canada Supplied by Ta
Board, 301.

Wood, William M., Addresses Letter to Wool
Growers' Convention, 2.

Wood, William M., Speaks Upon Injury to Wool Industry, 82.

Wool and Cotton Schedules Defended by Charles Heber Clark, 161' And Wool n Schedule to be Written in Two Days, 183; Growers and Manufacturers have armo of Interests, 4: Growers and Wool Manufacturers Should Stand Together, 1; Growers in Convention Addressed in Letter by A. D. Juilliard, 1; Growers of Montana SpeakLewiston (Mont.) "Argus," 281; Growers of Tri-States Resent Treaty-"National Stockman and Farmer, 188; Growers' Resolutions, 15; Growing and Manufacturing Menaced by Extra Session, 198; Growing to be Exterminated by Plan of Democrats, 347; Imports Show Increase Under Protection, 19; IndusLow

tries Damaged $150,000,000 Under Tariffs. 10; Manufactures Development Given By William Whitman, 46; Manufacturers Not in Favor of Reciprocity Scheme, 304; Manufacturers Say, What? 82; Schedule Not Discriminating in Carded Rates, 39; Schedule Revision Embarrasses Democrats, 286; Should Be Protected, Free Wool Unwise, 344; Tariffs Lowered Is Invariably Cause of Meat Shortage, 154: Woolen Blanket Again Brought Up in Washington, 220; Industry Shown to Be Menaced by Agreement, 339; Manufacture Development in United States, No. 23. Page IV; Manufacturer Has to Pay Duty On All His Machinery, 344; Mill Construction Cost Here and in Germany, 347; Tariff Effect if Reduced-New York "Sun," 368; Words of Good Cheer for the Tariff League, 53. Workingman Must Prepare to Work Cheap if He Buy Cheap, 221.

Workingmen Warned by Possible Result of Oriental Competition, 30.

Workman in Britain Victim of Cheapness, 44. Works, Judge, Not a Protectionist, but Insurgent, 44.

"World" Asks Opinion of George B. Curtiss on Agreement, 109. World-wide Reciprocity-Washington "Post,"

122.

YOUNG, John P., Gives Reasons for Oppos

ing Tariff Commission, 56.

Young, Lafayette, Attacks Motives of Selfish Newspapers, 315.

Young, Lafayette, Tells About Men Who Talk
Most, 276.

Young Senator. Able Advocate of Protection, 21.
Young, Senator. Consistent in His Stand Against
Reciprocity. 58.
Young's Sound
"Journal," 72.

Doctrine-Cambridge (M