and 146 New York State Reporter

First Department-Cont'd.
Justices of the Appellate Term, 1908—Cont'd.

June.
HENRY A. GILDERSLEEVE, PRESIDING JUSTICE.

ASSOCIATE JUSTICES.
SAMUEL SEABURY.

CHARLES F. MACLEAN.

October.
HENRY A. GILDERSLEEVE, PRESIDING JUSTICE.

ASSOCIATE JUSTICES.
PETER A. HENDRICK.

M. WARLEY PLATZEK.

November.
HENRY A. GILDERSLEEVE, PRESIDING JUSTICE,

ASSOCIATE JUSTICES.
LEONARD A. GIEGERICII

CHARLES L. GUY.

December.
HENRY A. GILDERSLEEVE, PRESIDING JUSTICE.

ASSOCIATE JUSTICES.
VERNON M. DAVIS.

JAMES A. BLANCHARD.

Justices of the First District. CHARLES F. MACLEAN.

HENRY BISCHOFF. EDWARD PATTERSON.

GEORGE L. INGRAHAM. CHARLES H. TRUAX.

VICTOR J. DOWLING. HENRY A. GILDERSLEEVE.

JOSEPH E. NEWBURGER. FRANCIS M. SCOTT.

JOHN J. BRADY. JAMES FITZGERALD.

CHARLES W. DAYTON. JAMES A. O'GORMAN.

MITCHELL L. ERLANGER. P. HENRY DUGR0.

JOHN FORD. JAMES A. BLANCHARD.

LEONARD A. GIEGERICH. JOHN PROCTOR CLARKE.

JOHN W. GOFF. SAMUEL GREENBAUM.

CHARLES L. GUY. EDWARD B. AMEND.

PETER A. HENDRICK. VERNON M. DAVIS.

M. WARLEY PLATZEK. EDWARD E. MCCALL.

SAMUEL SEABURY.
JAMES W. GERARD.

Second Department.
Justices of the Appellate Division.
MICHAEL H. HIRSCHBERG, PRESIDING JUSTICE.

ASSOCIATE JUSTICES.
JOHN WOODWARD.

WILLIAM J. GAYNOR. ALMET F. JENKS.

ADELBERT P. RICH. WARREN B. HOOKER.

NATHAN L. MILLER.

Second Department-Cont'd.

Justices of the Second District. WILLIAM J. GAYNOR.

LUKE D. STAPLETON. WILLIAM D. DICKEY.

JOSEPH ASPINALL. GARRET J. GARRETSON.

WILLIAM J. CARR. SAMUEL T. MADDOX.

LESTER W. CLARK. ALMET F. JENKS.

FREDERICK E. CRANE. JOSIAH T. MAREAN.

WALTER H. JAYCOX. WILLIAM J. KELLY.

TOWNSEND SCUDDER. JOSEPH A. BURR.

EDWARD B. THOMAS.
ABEL E. BLACKMAR.

Justices of the Ninth District. MARTIN J. KEOGH.

ISAAC N. MILLS. MICHAEL H. HIRSCHBERG. JOSEPH MORSCHAUSER.

ARTHUR S. TOMPKINS.

Third Department.

Justices of the Appellate Division.
WALTER LLOYD SMITH, PRESIDING JUSTICE.

ASSOCIATE JUSTICES.
ALDEN CHESTER.

AARON V. S. COCHRANE. JOHN M. KELLOGG.

ALBERT H. SEWELL.

Justices of the Third District. ALDEN CHESTER.

AARON V. S. COCHRANE. EMORY A. CHASE.1

WESLEY O. HOWARD. JAMES A. BETTS.

GEORGE H. FITTS.

Justices of the Fourth District.
CHESTER B. MCLAUGHLIN.2 HENRY T. KELLOGG.
JAMES W. HOUGHTON.2

JOHN M. KELLOGG.
EDGAR A. SPENCER.

CHARLES C. VAN KIRK.

Justices of the Sixth District. GEORGE F. LYON.

NATHAN L. MILLER.3 ALBERT H. SEWELL.

HENRY B. COMAN. WALTER LLOYD SMITH.

ALBERT F. GLADDING.

and 146 New York State Reporter

Fourth Department.

Justices of the Appellate Division.
PETER B. McLENNAN, PRESIDING JUSTICE.

ASSOCIATE JUSTICES.
ALFRED SPRING.

FREDERICK W. KRUSE.
PARDON C. WILLIAMS.

JAMES A, ROBSON.

Justices of the Fifth District.
WILLIAM E. SCRIPTURE.

WATSON M. ROGERS.
FRANK H. HISCOCK.4

IRVING R. DEVENDORF.
PARDON C. WILLIAMS.5

PASCAL C. J. DE ANGELIS.
WILLIAM S. ANDREWS.

PETER B. McLENNAN.5

Justices of the Seventh District.
ADELBERT P. RICH.6

ARTHUR E. SUTHERLAND.
JAMES A. ROBSON.5

GEORGE A. BENTON.
NATHANIEL FOOTE.

WILLIAM W. CLARK.
SAMUEL N. SAWYER.

Justices of the Eighth District.
CHARLES B. WHEELER.

FREDERICK W. KRUSE.5
FRANK C. LAUGHLIN.7

JOHN S. LAMBERT.
ALFRED SPRING.5

CHARLES H, BROWN.
TRUMAN C. WHITE.

EDWARD K. EMERY,
JOHN WOODWARD.7

LOUIS W. MARCUS.
WARREN B. HOOKER.

CUTHBERT W. POUND.

CITY COURT OF NEW YORK.
EDWARD F. O'DWYER, CHIEF JUSTICE,

ASSOCIATE JUSTICES.
JOHN H. MCCARTHY.

JOSEPH I. GREEN.
LEWIS J. CONLAN.

JOHN V. MCAVOY.
THEODORE F. HASCALL.

THOMAS F. DONNELLY.
FRANCIS B. DELEHANTY.

ALEXANDER FINELITE.
PETER SCHMUCK.

CASES REPORTED.

740

884

587

..........

...1143

.......1138

...1139

.......1122

Page

Page

Abbott, Tavshanjian v. (Sup.)..... 583 Bankers' Money Order Ass'n v. Nachod

Abbott Press, Rafter v.' (Sup.)...........1144 (Sup.) ...........

Abels-Gold Realty Co., Rothbard v. (Sup.) 526 Bankers' Surety Co., Sullivan v. (City Ct.

Abert v. Kornfeld (Sup.)......

N. Y.)...

173

i . ..

Abramowitz, Granit v. (Sup.). : : .........1081 Bantel, Allen v. (Sup.). ................11

A. Bushnell & Co., Hayes v. (Sup.)......1132 Barber v. Flint (Sup.).....

...1121

Adam, People

.1143 Barnes, Turin Cemetery v. (Sup.)........1149

Adams v. Bristol (Sup.)...

....1121 Barnet' Textile Co. v. Greilich (Sup.).....1122

Agnew, Firestone Tire & Rubber Co. v. Barnum, Lyons v. (Sup.).

| Barnwell, Will v. (Sup.).....

462

Aichmann v. People's Trust Co. (Sup.). ...1121 | Bashford, People v. (Sup.)...

502

Akers v. Mutual Life Ins. Co. of New York Bashford. People v. (Sup.).......

(Sup.) .........

254 Bastable v. Carroll (Sup.)........::

...1122

A. L. Clarke & Co., Hart v. (Sup.).. ....1131 | Batavia Home Tel. Co., Merger v. (Sup.). .1137

Alexander, Solomon v. (Sup.)......

... 779 Bates v. Delaware, L. & W. R. Co. (Sup.).. 1122

Allen v. Bantel (Sup.)........

...1121 | Battle Island Paper Co., Cullen v. (Sup.) 934

Allen, Parks v. (Sup.)......

...1140 Bauder, In re (Sup.).......

761

Allen Kingston Car Co. v. Consolidated | Bauer, O'Connor v. (Sup.)...

Nat. Bank (Sup.).......

...1121 Baxter v. York Realty Co. (Sup.)........ 455

American Butter Co., Brandley v. (Sup.). .1030 Bayless Pulp & Paper Co., Ouderkirk v.

American District Tel. Co. v. Woodbury

(Sup.).

(Sup.) ...

165 Bayne v. Bradwell (Sup.)...

American Exch. Nat. Bank, Fischer v. Beach, Lewis v. (Sup.)...

200

(Sup.) .

... 668

Beakes Dairy Co. v. Berns (Sup.)..... 529

American Fidelity Co., Foster v. (Sup.)...1129 Beal v. Bingham (Sup.).......

465

American Mahogany Co., McCabe v. Bear, Schlesinger v. (Sup.)....

826

...1135

Becher v. National Cloak & Suit Co. (Sup.) 839

American Pub. Ass'n. Straus v. (Sup.)....1148 Becker, In re (Sur.)...

221

Ames Iron Works, Duchambeau v. (Sup.). , 1127 Becker v. Interborough Rapid Transit Co.

Amos v. International R. Co. (Sup.)......1121 (Sup.) ...

816

Anderson, Dodd v. (Sup.).

... 414 Beers v. Strong (Sup.).......

382

Andrew Jergens Co. v. Woodbury (Sup.)..1121 Beever, Reese v. (Sup.).................1144

Andrews, In re (Sup.)..

Bell v. James (Sup.). .

Angus v. Comptroller of State of New

Bell Tel. Co., of Buffalo, Ziegler

York (Sup.) .....

(Sup.) ............:::

Anthony & Scovill Co., De La Vergne Co. Bellew & Merritt Co., Trotto v. (Sup.)....1148

V. (Sup.)......

1126 Belloff, Pretscher v. (Sup.).........

Appleby, Seneca Nation of Indians v. (Sup.) 177 Belmont St., In re (Sup.)......

.......1122

Ardolino v. Reinhardt (Sup.)....

641 Belmont Street in the City of New York,

Argyle Co. v. Griffith (Sup.)....... 773 In re (Sup.)......

....... 858

Argyle Co., Harrison v. (Sup.)........... Benjamin, Ryan v. (Sup.).....

.441

Arnold v. Arnold (Sup.)....

.....

.1121 Bennett v. Tucker Electrical Const. Co.

Asphalt Const. Co. y. Bouker (Sup.).... 31 (Sup.) ...

...1122

Atkins, Gasson v. (Co. Ct.)....

224 | Bennett's Will, In re (Sur.)........

592

.............

Atkinson v. Consolidated Rendering Co. Berenberg v. Bieber (Sup.).....

(Sup.) .....:::

.1121 Bernhard v. Rochester (Sup.)...

Autler Co. v. Rankin (Sup.)......

...........108

. 1085

Berns, Beakes Dairy Co. v. (Sup.) · 529

Automobile Club of America v. Canavan Betz, Yuengling v. (Sup.)....

1151

785 Bidwell, Warrillow v. (Sup.)...

.1149

Avery v. Brooklyn Heights R. Co. (Sup.). .1121 Bieber, Berenberg v. (Sup.)....... .1122

Bieber v. Rosengarten (Sup.).... ..1122

Bacigalupo v. Parrilli (Sup.).............1040 Bingham, Beal v. (Sup.)......

Baker v. Harvith (S

1121 Bingham, Hodgins v. (Sup.)...... • 543

Baltimore & O. R. Co. v. La Due (Sup.).. 964 Bingham, People v. (Sup.)....

.1142

Bang v. New York & Q. C. R. Co. (Sup.).. 530 Bingham, People v. (Sup.)..

.1143

Bankers' Life Ins. Co. of City of New Birchell, Monds V. (Sup.).

York, Hill v. (Sup.)......

120 Bister v. Greenberg (Sup.)...

.1122

Bankers' Money Order Ass'n v. Nachod

Bittman v. Duckworth (Sup.)...... .1122

(Sup.) .......

... 721 | Blair v. Keese (Sup.)........

162

112 N.Y.S.

(vii)

.. 167

"

.......1144

1122

229

.... 465

• 249

:..... 578

......1122

.... 549

...............112

............1122

... 890

.......1123

.... 243

and 146 New York State Reporter

Page

Page

Blum v. New York (Sup.). ...............102. |

......1071 Brown V. New York (Sup.), .....

.1123

Blum v. Union R. Co. (Sup.)....

Brown Bros. Co., Smith v. (Sup.).......1147

Board of Assessors of City of Buffalo, Peo Browne, Egan y. (Sup.). .................

.: 889

ple v. (Sup.).....

.1141 Brownell, In re (Sur.)................. 597

Board of Education of City of New York, Brown's Estate, In re(Sur.).....

599

Loewy v. (Sup.)....

Brunn, Compagnie Commerciale v. (Sup.)..1125

vard of Education of City of New York, Buffaló, Economic Power & Const. Co. v.

Wood v. (Sup.)....

(Sup.) ..

......1127

Board of Education, O'Rourke v. (Sup.). .1139 Buffalo, Empire Limestone Co. v. (Sup.)..1128

Board of Rapid Transit Com'rs, In re Buffalo, McDougall v. (Sup.).............1136

(Sup.) ....

Buffalo, Miller v. (Sup.). .

.1137

Board of Rapid Transit R. Com’rs, In re Buffalo, New York Cent. & H. R. R. Co. v.

(Sup.) .......

(Sup.)

.. 997

Bogart' v. New

isinin

York (Sup.).....

Buffalo, Pryor v. (Sup.)....

Bologh y. Roof Maintenance Co. (Sup.)....1104 Buffalo, White v. (Sup.)...

485

Bond Realty Co. v. Pounds (Sup.)........ 433 Buffalo Commercial Ins. Co. v. Georger

Bonewur, Great Northern Moulding Co. v.

(Sup.) ......

:1123

(Sup.) ....

Buffaló Expanded Metal Co., Hartmetz v.

Bonewur, Great Northern Moulding Co. v. (Sup.) ..

..1131

(Sup.) ............

..1131 Buffalo Forge Co. v. Columbus & Hocking

Bonhoff v. Fischer (Sup.)...

Clay Const. Co. (Sup.)...

460

Boniface v. McAvoy (Sup.)..............1122

1122 Buffalo Gas Co., City of Buffalo v. (Sup.).. 468

Bonsall, Platt v. (Sup.)......

. 1143 Buffalo Merchants' Delivery Co. v. Fron-

Borchert v. Manhattan Transfer Co. (Sup.)1122 tier Tel. Co. (Sup.). .....

Borges V. Freedman (Sup.).....

(1122 Buffalo & L. È. Traction Co., Crimi v.

Boskowitz v. Sulzbacher (Sup.). .......

(Sup.) ........

........1126

Boston Ins. Co., Hupfel v. (Sup.).....

Burghen v. Savage (Sup.)...............1123

Bottsford-Dickinson Co., McNeill v. (Sup.) 867 Burke v. Continental Ins. Co. of City of

Bouker, Asphalt Const. Co. v. (Sup.)...... 31 New York (Sup.)........

Bow, People v. (Sup.).....

......1140 Burke v. International Paper Co. (Sup.).. 893

Boyce, Witkop & Holmes Co. v. (Sup.)... 874 Burns v. Staunton (Sup.).....

Boyd v. Boyd (Sup.)...

.1122 | Burr, Morris v. (Sup.)..

Boyer v. Metropolitan Sewing Mach. Co. Burwell's Estate, In re (Sup.)............1123

. 817 | Bushbey, In re (Sur.)...

Boyington, Genesee River R. Co. v. (Sup.) 343 Bushinger v. Miller (Sup.)...

..1123

Bradley v. Krudop (Sup.)...

...... 609 | Bushnell v. Syracuse Rapid Transit R. Co.

Bradshaw v. Mutual Life Ins. Co. of New

(Sup.) .....

.1123

York (Sup.) .......

107 Bushnell & Co., IIayes v. (Sup.)..........1132

Bradwell, Bayne v. (Sup.)....... ...1122 Busse, Clement v. (Sup.)................1125)

Brady, McGill v. (Sup.).................1136

| Butler, People v., six cases (Sup.)........1142

Brady, People v. (Sup.)....

..1141 Butler, People v., four cases (Sup.). .....1143

Brady, People v. (Sup.)...

....1142 | Butterick Pub. Co. v. Chabot (Sup.)...,1123

Brandlev v. American Butter Co. (Sup.). 1030 | Byrne. In re (S

699

Breck v. United States Title Guaranty & Byrne v. Lathrop, 'Shea & Henwood Co.

Indemnity Co. (Sup.).................. 756

(Sup.) ...:::

273

Brick v. Shaff (Sup.)...

.....: 642 | Byrnes v. McNevin (Sup.)..............1064

Briscoe v. Metropolitan Life Ins. Co.

(Sup.) ...........

..1123 Cahzin v. Cahzin (Sup.)................

.. .........

Bristol, Adams v. (Sup.)...

...1121 | Caldwell v. Glazier (Sup.)..

655

British America Assur. Co., Kub v. (Sup.) 410 Calkins, Lyons Beet Sugar Refining Co. v.

Brockway, Kiley v. (Sup.).......

..1134 (Sup.) .....

..1135

Brooklyn Heights R. Co., Avery v. (Sup.)..1121 Callahan v. David M. Oltarsh Iron Works

Brooklyn Heights R. Co., Eisenbauer v.

(Sup.) ..............................1102

(Sup.)

......1128 Calvert v. Calvert (Sup.). .

Sup.)...............1123

Brooklyn Heights R. Co., Graef v. (Sup.). .1131 Canavan, Automobile Club of America v.

Brooklyn Heights R. Co., Magagnos v. (Sup.).

(Sup.) .

637 candeeFowler Plumbing & Heating Co."

Brooklyn Heights R.* * Co., Mahon v. v. (Sup.)...

Canfield v. New York Transp. Co. (Sup.). . 854

Brooklyn, Q. C. & S. R. Co., Catzer v. Carlin Const. Co., Egan v. (Sup.)........1128

(Sup.) ..

..1088 Carlson v. Von Hoveling American Compo

Brooklyn, Q. c. & S. R. Co., Gabel v. sition Co. (Sup.)......................1123

....

Carolan v. O'Donnell (Sup.).............1124

Brooklyn, Q. C. & S. R. Co., Gertler v. Carroda v. Foundation & Contracting Co.

(Sup.)

.......1130

(Sup.) ....:::::

Brooklyn Rapid Transit Co., Ronero v. Carroll, Bastable v. (Sup.)...

.1122

(Sup.) :

..1145 Carroll v. New York, N. H. & H. R. Co.

Brown, Gaylord v. (Sup.)...

745 (Sup.) :::::

Brown, Gaylord v. (Sup.).

748 | Casey v. Lehigh Valley R. Co. (Sup.)..... 522

Brown' v. Grossman (Sup.)..

827 | Casper Iba Const. Co., South Brooklyn
Brown v. Newell (Sup.)......

..1123 | Realty Co. v. (Sup.)......

...... 262

......1136

....1082

......1117