Entered according to act of Congress, in the year one thousand nine hundred and three,

By J. B. LYON COMPANY,
in the office of the Librarian of Congress, at Washington.

Ree, Feat: 28,1903.

J. B. LYON COMPANY,
PRINTERS, ELECTROTYPERS AND BINDERS,

LYON BLOCK, ALBANY, N. Y.

OF

THE APPELLATE DIVISION OF THE SUPREME COURT.

First Department.
HON. CHAS. H. VAN BRUNT, P.J.

EDWARD PATTERSON.
MORGAN J. O'BRIEN.
GEORGE L. INGRAHAM.
CHESTER B. MOLAUGHLIN.
EDWARD W. HATCH.

FRANK C. LAUGHLIN.
Second Department.
Hon. WILLIAM W. GOODRICH, P. J.

WILLARD BARTLETT.
JOHN WOODWARD.
MICHAEL H. HIRSCHBERG.
ALMET F. JENKS.

WARREN B. HOOKER.*
Third Department,
Hon. CHARLES E. PARKER, P. J.

WALTER LLOYD SMITH.
S. ALONZO KELLOGG.
EMORY A. CHASE.
ALDEN CHESTER.

GEORGE F. LYON.
Fourth Department.
Hon. WILLIAM H. ADAMS, P. J.

PETER B. MOLENNAN.
ALFRED SPRING.
PARDON C. WILLIAMS.
FRANK H. HISCOCK,
EDWIN A. NASH.*

66

Division Reports have been passed upon by the Court of
Appeals.

ALBRING 0, NEW YORK CENTRAL & H. R. R. R Co..... 73 App. Div. 620

Order affirmed : 174 N. Y. 179.
BENSON 0. EASTERN BUILDING & LOAN ASSN.....

67 App. Div. 319
Judgment reversed : 174 N. Y. 83.
BORNMANN v. STAR Co......

72 App. Div. 633 Judgment affirmed : 174 N. Y. 212. BRANTINGHAM 0. HUFF

67 App. Div, 621 Judgment reversed : 174 N. Y. 53. COLUMBIA BANK O. BIRKETT

65 App. Div. 615
Judgmont affirmed : 174 N. Y. 112.
CUDLIP 0. NEW YORK EVENING JOURNAL PUB. Co........... 70 App. Div. 617

Judgment reversed : 174 N. Y. 158.
DEVOE 0. N. Y. C. & H. R. R. R. Co ......

70 App. Div. 495 Order of Appellate Division reversed, and that of trial court affirmed : 174 N. Y. 1. GREENWALD 0. WALES....

67 App. Div. 628 Judgment reversed : 174 N. Y. 140. HOAG 0. WRIGHT....

69 App. Div. 381 Judgment reversed : 174 N. Y. 36. JONES O. REILLY..

68 App. Div. 116 Judgment reversed : 174 N. Y. 97. KANE CO. 0. KINNEY...

68 App. Div. 163 Judgment reversed : 174 N. Y. 69. LAHEY D. LAHEY .

66 App. Div. 623 Judgment affirmed : 174 N. Y. 146. LINDENTHAL 0. GERMANIA LIFE IN8. Co....

65 App. Div. 615 Judgment reversed : 174 N. Y. 76. MATTER OF CITY OF NEW YORK..

74 App. Div. 197 Order affirmed : 174 N. Y. 26. MATTER OF CUSACK 0. BD. OF EDUCATION..

78 App. Div. 470 Order reversed : 174 N. Y. 136. MATTER OF FITZSIMONS

77 App. Div. 345 Order of Appellate Division reversed and order of Surrogate's Court afirmed :

174 N. Y. 15. MATTER OF HELLMAN..

77 App. Div. 355 Order reversed : 174 N. Y. 254.

78 App. Div. 644 Order reversed : 174 N. Y. 87.

68 App. Div. 650 Judgment reversed : 174 N. Y. 108. PEOPLE EX REL. CALLAHAN 0. BOARD OF EDUCATION....... 78 App. Div. 501

Order affirmed : 174 N. Y. 169.

MATTER OF SUGDEN...

MEAD 0. DUNLEVIE

V